EleqTrizi'T

<a href="http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,93245,00.html">Story</a>

My only question is... if a girl falsely claims she said "no" in an attempt to sandbag you, how can it be proven or disproven?

It worries me because I can see men getting put away on a woman's word alone.

I agree with the premise, just worry about the implementation.

lurkette

I worry, too. Does regret after the fact count as "no"? And geez - once you've gotten on the train it's kind of hard to put on the breaks. I can see where they'd want to protect people who changed their mind in the middle of the act, but this seems like it would just muddy the waters. It's already very difficult to prove consent/lack of consent when it's a he-said-she-said situation.

__________________
"If ten million people believe a foolish thing, it is still a foolish thing."

- Anatole France

twotimesadingo

Sadly, many of the rape cases already are built on a "he said, she said" foundation. The addition of this law would only make things much harder for the male, and much easier for smear campaigns to be conducted.

I'd say your conclusion is fairly accurate, Eleq.

__________________
I'll be the one to protect you from your enemies and all your demons.
I'll be the one to protect you from a will to survive and voice of reason.
I'll be the one to protect you from your enemies and your choices, son.
They're one and the same I must isolate you, isolate and save you from yourself."
- A Perfect Circle

geodaro

I'm not sure, maybe we should just wait and ask Kobe what he thinks?!

MSD

I think what needs to be done is to establish a national safe-word, like "Armadillo." Not only would it indicate a desire to stop sex, I think if I was in the middle of the act and a girl started shouting "Armadillo, armadillo!" I'd probably lose my erection.

But seriously, I think that what really needs to happen is that people need to make sure they're comfortable with each other before having sex, and understand what the limits are, and be sensetive enough to each other that they're able and willing to stop if it is requested. I realy don't think there's any way that a law like this could be implemented safely without negative side-effects, like regrets after the fact.

tinfoil

Goodness, with laws like this it is getting to the point where you need a lawyer and a contract before you hop in the sack.

__________________
Get off your fuckin cross. We need the fuckin space to nail the next fool martyr.

anteros

No kidding. I'm going to start printing up forms. Sign here, initial here, here and here, three forms of id, and a spinal tap, then we can get it on. Jesus

Fallon

Sad thing is anteros that you are probably on the right track.

sexymama

Very sad and scary! What makes it worse, is the girls parents can call rape even if she consented. Not only do you need a contract, you must check id to assure she is over 18! (Which is not fair to the younger male population!) MrSelfDestruct is right on about getting to know each other first -- including her age!

__________________
If you can go deeply into lovemaking, the ego disappears. That is the beauty of lovemaking, that it is another source of a glimpse of god

It's not about being perfect; it's about developing some skill at managing imperfection.

motdakasha

The national-safe word is a good idea because what if the girl answers no to a question while having sex. "Do you want me to stop?" "No." omg rape! I doubt you'd be talking about armadillos while having sex.

__________________
=^-^= motdakasha =^-^=
Just Google It.
BA Psychology & Photography
(I'm not going psychoanalyze you nor will I let you cry on my shoulder. Have a nice day.)

RAGEAngel9

Well actually satchitory(sp? whatever ) works both ways if both kids are under 18. So if the parents of the girl cry rape, then both kids are in trouble. This is only the case for under age sex rape, not non consenual rape.(Did that make sense?)
However, if the guy is over 18, he's possibly fucked. Depends on the prosecuter, parents, ages, and other stuff.
When I was with my ex, I was a few motnhs older. Once I was 18 but she was still 17, I was afraid of pissing off her parents for the fact if they found out we were havign sex, they could have brought charges against me. Whether or not they realy would have, I was just nervous.

tritium

Like previously stated, I, too, agree with the premise but fear the implications of yet another "rape law." Why don't we just start bagging up all men and shipping them off to prison for life -- starting with the loser that wrote and proposed this legislation (probably male). I also believe that a man can be raped too, but the law doesn't allow for that.

__________________
Blah.

chavos

Not sure i have the most understanding for someone who can't come to their senses when a girl cries out "stop" from underneath them. Yeah, i know there's a moment of no return, but i don't think that means the guy has rights to finish if he manages to get it in before she says no.

hobo

This stuff just scares me. I am tempted to draft a contract in which it will clearly state that "The woman who's signature rests upon the line below has consented to sex with __(my name)__."

MrFlux

This is the reason why one night stands are bad... well, one of the reasons anyway

__________________
flux (n.)
Medicine. The discharge of large quantities of fluid material from the body, especially the discharge of watery feces from the intestines.

tenchi069

Hello Mr. Jones, this is Samantha down at Herskowitz, Dennin, and Carpenter attorneys at law. I'm just calling to inform your that your girlfriends lawyers have set over the final draft and weve looked it over and approved. if you would just stop by the office by 8pm this evening you will be legally authorized to engaged in penal-vaginal intercourse, and oral intercourse. anal intercourse is permitted only only when biline 3.2 has been fulfilled, and failure to warn about premature ejaculation during oral intercourse will null and void this contract as stipulated in paragraph 6 subsection 2. Thank you and have a great day you spontaneous romantic.


*Disclaimer* the above paragraph is a parody and in no such way form or fashion denotes any negativity to Mr. Jones, Samantha, Herskowitz, Dennin, and or Carpenter. Any similarities to any person living or dead is purely coincidental.

Ralvek

So here's my question...if you try to stick it in her ass and she says no...is that rape?

__________________
Ban country music, it promotes inbreeding.

reverendjay

This is all coming from a California Rape case where two 17 year olds began having consensual sex, and at some point the girl decided she was no longer into it and asked him to stop. Eventually he did, but the courts felt that he didn't stop fast enough. Lurkette regret after the fact is not considered rape according to this law, either party must indicate their wish to stop verbally at some point during the act of intercourse for this law to take effect. If the other party continues sexual relations beyond that point it becomes rape.

Rage statutory rape comes into play when only one of the participants is underage, and the difference in ages is greater than the limit set by the state you're having sex in. In most states it's legal for an 18 y/o to have sex with a 17 y/o, but not a 20 y/o with a 16y/o.

__________________
I'm married now, so the only thing in my house that pulls out now is the couch.

Subform

Obviously the male will always be in the vulnerable end of the situation of this .. !
Sometimes this is needed, but many times aswell, the man is marely having a good time with a girl that changes her mind.

__________________
-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+
Subform - Allover the place