Jadedfox

OK since we have a thread for GOTY 2004, I figured I'd start a thread for the most disappointing game of the year since there are no threads on it (I think, search didn't find any).

My nomination goes to Doom3. For all the hype and talk this game has to take the prize. Maybe it's just me but walking around in complete darkness with a flashlight in endless repetition is just not fun.

The most fitting words I can think of to describe Doom3 comes from Andre Linoge in the Stephen King movie "Storm of the Century" and they are:

"Hell is repetition"

Oh how true it is for this game.

--jaded

__________________
There is no fucking you, there is only me.

buclao

Fable

For all the time that it took to develop, it should've really been much longer. I'm not saying that Fable was a bad game, but there really should've been more.

Ripsaw

Ditto for Doom 3. I was just... underwhelmed by the flashlight mechanics.

__________________
"We are supposed to be masters of space, but we cant even line up our shoes?"

One life, one chance, one opportunity.

Kadath

Star Wars Battlefront. LucasArts continues its "hit or miss" ways.

__________________
it's quiet in here

the_marq

While I agree that Doom3 was far from perfect, the most disappointing game for me was; Prince of Persia: The Warrior Within.

I just started playing it and so far, it sucks. I doubt very much that I will finish it.

The gameplay is just way too different from the first POP (Sands of Time). POP:WW is much darker and more violent than was SOT and much more focused on swordplay rather than puzzle solving. Also, what happened to the thematicly friendly Arabian music from the first one? If I wanted to hear shitty synth-metal I'd buy a LimpBizkit CD.

Oh, BattleFront also sucked, but that's no surprise.

__________________
The Truth:

Johnny Cash could have kicked Bruce Lee's ass if he wanted to.

#3 in a series

Church

Goldeneye: Rogue Agent. Looked amazing before it came out, now I think its total garbage.

__________________
Through counter-intelligence, it should be possible to pinpoint potential trouble makers, and neutralize them.

Carno

Fable

What a waste of money that game was.

AndTylerToo

Definately Doom 3. I gave it many, many chances, and it just never redeemed itself. :\

bundy

definitely Fable.
and the ending for HALO2 pissed me off something rotten as well... but that doesn't mean to say that the game itself wasn't brilliant.

__________________
Ohayo!!!

Arc101

Another vote for Doom 3 - It was ok but should have been far better with the amount of time it took to produce.

Coppertop

Lords of the Realm 3 hands down. I had much hope for this game as the 2nd one was excellent in almost every way. So very sad. In retrospect I should have known something was wrong when it was priced $20 on launch day.

dabossy2k

Man I didn't like EQ 2 and Fable is on my list of disappointments as well.

__________________
Recovering nice guy

Scipio

Doom 3. It was cool for a while, but now I'm like "what the hell was I thinking?" I didn't quite finish it, and I'm never going back.

__________________
"Erections lasting more than 4 hours, though rare, require immediate medical attention."

MPower

Looks like we have a console vs pc bad game fight going on. I have a PC and will go with Doom3 also. Wasnt a stinker, but with all the hype and time it could have been better.

Results so far...

PC - Doom3
Console - Fable

Mr.Deflok

Star Wars - Battlefront: it just felt incredibly boring and shallow, especially for a Star Wars game.

Half-Life 2: again, this game felt shallow and lacked purpose. It's physic innovations were fantastic but served no real purpose other than to show off when the intention of the game is to be a revolutionary epic with a strong storyline pulling it along.

Ninja Gaiden: sure it's pretty but so incredibly boring!

Need for Speed Undeground 2: basically part one with a free roam feature and even dumber AI.

Hyper Street Fighter II (PAL): missed out on SFIII and played like a hacked arcade version of SFII (to counter this though the Xbox version was fucking brilliant).

Mortal Kombat Deception: chess Kombat was cool, konquest was cool, puzzle kombat was cool but the core ingredient, the actual fighting, was poor and sub-standard.

Spiderman 2: I can't honestly see why this game was being praised so much, it looked horrendous and was nothing new or exciting. The missions were bland and uneventful and overall it was just an average movie tie-in.

Prince of Persia - Warrior Within: they took part one and stripped away all the clever goodness about it, added a pathetic cliched heavy metal score and turned the game into an 'edgy' and 'alternative' bloodfest. What a fucking joke.

blitz.fenix

Calk up another vote for Doom 3. It was one of te most boring games I have played in my entire life. Not ever have I been bored with a game within the first half hour of playing it.

then00b

Killzone. Was supposed to be this massive Halo killer. Yup, it sucks. So much for the halo 2 pwnage.

Rabid Bunny

Add another tally for Doom 3. God, the only amusement I had from that game was changing the flashlight in the game to a picture of Jesus. Certainly scared those demons away.

docbungle

Halo 2
Fable

Both overhyped and underwhelming.

__________________
Bad Luck City

Xenomorph

Doom 3 gets my vote. The flashlight trick was interesting the first 2 times, but building an entire game around it got ridiculous. They called the keys PDAs in this version, but it was still a nearly linear, key-driven shooter. It would have been great in a time before games like Half Life and Deus Ex moved us past that sort of thing, but its just a bunch of tired mechanics wrapped up in new paper.

__________________
The facehugger is short-lived outside the egg which normally protects it. Armed with a long grasping tail, a spray of highly-concentrated acid and the single-minded desire to impregnate a single selected prey using its extending probe, it will fearlessly pursue and attack a single selected target until it has succeeded in attachment or it or its target is dead

FngKestrel

Doom 3 was scary, but wasn't as engaging as many of the other games I played. Fable didn't quite live up to the hype, and I think Peter Molyneux knew that. However, I did enjoy that game thoroughly and was much more engaged by it than Doom 3.

So my vote is for Doom 3. They tried to accomplish the anti-thesis of Quake 3, and while Carmack can write a good engine, I'm less than impressed with their story telling abilities.

pippepin

doom3, i played it for a few hours and became thoroughly bored and uninstalled. haven't second thought it since

Ace_O_Spades

Wow I'm glad someone mentioned Lords of the Realm 3

What a piece of shit... LOTR 2 was such a rad game too... Sad

__________________
Feh.

GakFace

Fable is on here? Ya know guys... if you ignore the hype then the games actually attain that fun factor that the hype was trying to say. I ignore it all, I listen enough to see whats coming out and cool features, then I shut it off until its released. I do the same with movies and it makes things MUCH more enjoyable in the end. As for Spidey 2.. it was praised because you can spend an hour just web slinging around and jumping buildings... running across the entire city sideway on a building..... Thats why so many of us love it

For me it was Tribes: Vegeance. I love tribes.. I still play Tribes2.. but they fucked this one up. The Single player isn't bad sure.. but its not Tribes. This is just a new game with the Tribes title. The mutliplayer just doesn't have the Tribes feel... I'm still playing UT when I played Vengeance.. it wasn't a Tribes feel.. but UT. If I wanted UT I'd play UT... not Tribes. Then another beef... The reason you couldn't go prone in Tribes 2 is because that wasn't a part of FPSs yet. But now it is and Tribes is known for large Multiplayer maps and snipers that can hide 2 miles away. Now tell me.. wouldn't it make a bit more sense to go prone on the top of that mountain instead of standing out like a sore thumb? Once it hits the bargain bin I'll buy it for the SP.. but thats about it. They completely ruined it for me.

__________________
RoboBlaster:
Welcome to the club! Not that I'm in the club. And there really isn'a a club in the first place. But if there was a club and if I was in it, I would definitely welcome you to it.

Echodork

Fable.

"Disappointment" means hearing a lot of hype about a game that can't live up to it. That's basically what the topic of the thread is :P Yes, Fable was extremely disappointing, because they promised so much, and delivered so little.

jmad

wow, lords of the realm. That brings back some great memories *sniff*. My vote goes for Halo 2. Still play the first one religiously.

MahlerIsGod

Cheers to jmad for having the balls to vote for Halo 2. Doom 3 was just OK and Fable simply annoying so my vote also goes to Halo 2. If MS was smart they would make Halo their launch game for each new console. I personally wouldn't have minded the wait if it was a better game.

__________________
"But a work of art is a conscious human effort that has to do with communication. It is that or its nothing. When an accident is applauded as a work of art, when a cult grows up around the deliciousness of inadvertent beauty, we are in the presence of the greatest decadence the West has known in its history."

DJMala

Yet another one for Doom3.

I really, really tried to like it. I even thought it was pretty good, at first, until HL2 came out. Since then, I've beaten Half-Life once already and I'm about 85% through a second play-through, plus I've replayed a few assorted chapters. In Doom, I'm still less than halfway through the first time. Half-Life has one too many show-off-the-physics-engine teeter-totter puzzles, but overall it's just better designed and more compelling.

whocarz

Doom 3 for me as well. It was scary for all of 2 minutes then it devolved into repetative teleport ambushes. Yawn.

__________________
If there exists anything mightier than destiny, then it is the courage to face destiny unflinchingly. -Geibel

Despise not death, but welcome it, for nature wills it like all else. -Marcus Aurelius

Come on, you sons of bitches! Do you want to live forever? -GySgt. Daniel J. "Dan" Daly

Nikilidstrom

Fable by a long shot. Looked great, but had nothing to support all the ground breaking, genre smashing hype that was put out about it. What ashame, it had so much potential.

Killzone would be a runner up, but I was in on the beta testing for that, so it wasn't much of a suprise to me that it wasn't all they hyped it to be.

Ultimate_Gohan

Mine are HALO 2 for XBOX and Yu Yu Hakusho for ps2.
Halo is very repetative and First person shooters are all starting to feel the same.
As for Yu Yu Hakusho. Good charater graphics and selection but the stupid controlls, ugly backgrounds and stupid music really disappointed me because I liked the show.

bigd999

Another vote for doom 3. The game just got very boring to me after the first couple of hours. Sure it was scary, but I need a better story than what it offered.

omega2K4

Doom 3, what a shitty game. All graphics and no substance.

__________________
"While the State exists there can be no freedom. When there is freedom there will be no State." - Vladimir Ilyich Lenin

"Reason has always existed, but not always in a reasonable form."- Karl Marx

FL8ME

I can't believe I'm the first person to say GTA: San Andreas. Don't get me wrong, I played all the way through and had a great time, but it just wasn't as good as Vice City. Sure it's a lot bigger, there are more varied missions, the vehicles are better..., now that I think about it, everything in San Andreas was done bigger and better than the previous new generation GTA games. It just simply wasn't as fun. For all the hype, I thought it was going to blow my mind. It entertained me and kept me coming back until I got 100%, but after that I took the disk out and popped Vice City back in for my favorite aspect of the game. The random, running around mayhem.

In conclusion, San Andreas was good fun, but after all the hype I was disappointed.

hulk

Heh, like I said in another thread, you'd think we'd have learnt by now that no game ever lives up to the hype.

Except Metroid Prime *giggle*

I'm a bit (well, a lot) of a cynical bastard when it comes to big-buget mainstream games that the current generation of fanboys proclaims mindlessly to be the best game ever (Halo 2, Half Life 2, Doom 3 etc) so I'm never surprised to find out that, when they do come out, they're not that great. So the biggest disappointment for me, this year, would have to be finding out that Gladius wasn't being carried by any stores in Australia. Spewing.

__________________
"'There's a tendency among the press to attribute the creation of a game to a single person,' says Warren Spector, creator of Thief and Deus Ex."
-- From an IGN game review.

Jadedfox

I disagree a bit here. I think WoW was pretty hyped and it certainly has lived up to it in my opinion. Maybe not as hyped as Halo 2, Doom3 and Fable but still.

--jaded

__________________
There is no fucking you, there is only me.

Lasereth

I'm starting to notice that fanboys aren't about praising a game that they enjoy anymore...it's about bashing good games instead. No longer is it Sega sux and Nintendo rox or Sony sux dix with Microsux. Now it's Halo 2, Half-Life 2, San Andreas, MGS 3, and every other game released this year are terrible games that are extremely disappointing. I'm starting to notice a major trend. Most of these fanboys will not accept that some games simply live up to their hype. Most of these fanboys will not accept that just because a game doesn't do everything that was promised doesn't mean it is a bad game. And it's really starting to annoy the shit outta me.

-Lasereth

__________________
"A Darwinian attacks his theory, seeking to find flaws. An ID believer defends his theory, seeking to conceal flaws." -Roger Ebert

Mephisto2

Doom 3.

I paid ~$2,000 for the guts of a new PC then bought two games to put it through its paces. HL2 and Doom3.

I'm still playing HL2 (only get free time when the wife isn't around!). I played the beginning of Doom3 for about 15 minutes. YAWWWWNNN....

CHING CHING, you just picked up an armour shard.

Gimme a break...


Mr Mephisto

mr sticky

I dunno Las, there are some issues with these games. I was disappointed in several. Not that they weren't good games, but the companies built us up for a grand adventure and didn't deliver. Halo 2 was supposed to be just like the first, only better. Well, it's not like the first. It's got some improvements, but also some comprimises. The stuff they comprimised on was some of the stuff I personally liked. So... I'm a little rough on them. They may not have comprimised on the stuff you liked about it. I hope that's the case. But, paying fifty bucks entitles you to an opinion.

__________________
The sad thing is... as you get older you come to realize that you don't so much pilot your life, as you just try to hold on, in a screaming, defiant ball of white-knuckle anxious fury

Lasereth

Well critiquing a game is fine but the guys I'm talking about say the games are complete trash. That's what gets on my nerves.

-Lasereth

__________________
"A Darwinian attacks his theory, seeking to find flaws. An ID believer defends his theory, seeking to conceal flaws." -Roger Ebert