Doom 3 was scary, but wasn't as engaging as many of the other games I played. Fable didn't quite live up to the hype, and I think Peter Molyneux knew that. However, I did enjoy that game thoroughly and was much more engaged by it than Doom 3.
So my vote is for Doom 3. They tried to accomplish the anti-thesis of Quake 3, and while Carmack can write a good engine, I'm less than impressed with their story telling abilities.
|