Originally Posted by CBC News

Canadians will vote for senators under new bill
Last Updated: Wednesday, December 13, 2006 | 12:37 PM ET
CBC News

Prime Minister Stephen Harper introduced a Senate reform bill Wednesday that gives Canadians a say about who represents them.

The bill, which falls short of allowing full Senate elections, calls for voters to choose preferred candidates to represent their provinces and territories.

The prime minister would then appoint the senators.

Liberal Leader Stéphane Dion has lashed out against the bill, calling it irresponsible, but Harper says it is a step forward.

"This bill will allow us to move to a new era in Canadian democracy," Harper told his cheering caucus at a meeting Wednesday morning in Ottawa.

"Imagine that after a century and a half, democracy will finally come to the Senate of Canada."
Continue Article


The prime minister currently appoints senators without seeking public input. There are Senate elections in Alberta and British Columbia, but they are non-binding and the results are traditionally ignored by the government.

If passed into law, the bill would allow Harper to make changes to the Senate without reworking the Constitution, which would require co-operation from the provinces.

Harper said he expects the Liberals to oppose the bill. He said they have given his government a hard time with almost every change, from cuts to the GST to the new Accountability Act.

"I don't expect them to embrace Senate reform without a fight," he said. "If they wanted Senate reform, they would have done it themselves."
Dion calls bill "completely irresponsible"

Dion said changes to the Senate should address more pressing concerns.

He said the current system doesn't make sense because a province like Nova Scotia is represented by 10 senators, while a province like Alberta, with about five times the population, only has six senators.

"I think what the prime minister wants to do is completely, completely irresponsible," Dion said in French, speaking to reporters a few hours after Harper's caucus meeting.

"We would be electing senators with the current distribution and the current distribution does penalize provinces, particularly the western provinces."

Activist says bill 'a long time coming'

Bert Brown, an Alberta man who has been fighting for Senate reform for more than 20 years, said Harper's bill has been a long time coming.

When Alberta decided to hold its own Senate elections, Brown ran in three such races and won twice, but the government never appointed him to the Senate.

Brown says Harper should start the election process immediately and fill a dozen vacant seats.

"They could just have a very simple message of going to their electorate and saying people can run for the nomination process, and go forward and have an election," he said. "It's not a painful process. I've been through it three times."

Harper has talked of Senate reform for years. He officially promised change in a speech in Vancouver a year ago, when he laid out his party's platform for the January 2006 election and called the appointed Senate a "relic of the 19th century.

"We need a ballot with senators' names, and seats with senators that have been elected," he told his supporters at the time.

Originally Posted by Charlatan

By the way, is it just me or does this really underscore Harper's hypocrisy? His appointing of a crony into the Senate and then giving him a cabinet position... the guy has never been elected (and there was a seat open where he could have run in a by-election).