Okay, how about this, a secondary tie breaker that only counts if two people have the same number of correct picks and the same initial tiebreaker number. The secondary tiebreaker is choosing which team will have the most points scored for the week. This will only be used if the highest scoring people have the same tiebreaker number. If it's still a tie, fuck it, I'm flipping a coin.
Again, if anyone has any better ideas, feel free to make them in this thread or PM me about it.