Maybe rather than merging a bunch of old threads (I never liked merging threads), we could have the people that want the sticky just start a health and fitness post with their goals in mind, then if it takes off and becomes sticky-worthy we can go from there.
I think the main way to go would just be a collection of resources, websites, books, advice, magazines, etc. As people post suggestions get added to the first post. There are other threads that fit this model.
See:
http://www.tfproject.org/tfp/tilted-...ding-list.html
http://www.tfproject.org/tfp/tilted-...re-thread.html
In that vein, I have some suggestions if someone wants to get the thread started
Books:
Websites:
Men's Health Fitness
Men's Health Nutrition
Runner's World
Nutrition Data