I personally like the timelessmessage.com bottle. it's more old fashioned and looks more romantic. But for the second bottle... the "key to the heart" part of the gift is very cute... so you know your wife better...
would she go for the romantic/old style bottle or the more modern one with the key to the heart?
You are really putting a lot of wonderful thought into this, it's touching to see someone care so deeply about their wife. Reminds me of my husband and trust me... wives love it when their husbands get a little mushy and uber romantic from time to time
your wife is a lucky woman to have you as you are her.
sp