Quote:
|
Originally Posted by SirLance
Intense1, welcome to TFP. It is a very cool, diverse, free thinking place.
I was raised Catholic and educated by Jesuits, who taught me critical thinking, a tool which has served me well. Faith cannot be taught, it is a gift.
They never said so, but I think what underscored the Jesuit's philosophy was that faith in God, while a gift, is also a choice, and should be an educated choice, and freely made. True faith can't come from indoctrination. How can it, when there is no room for doubt.
I am probably misquoting, but I believe it was Gallileo who said "God gave me a mind that I might use it."
These kids will have a harder time spiritually because they will be denied the struggle that strengthens faith. I'm sure these people believe they are doing these kids a service and somehow imbuing them with a firm belief, but really they are harming their long-term spiritual development.
I pray that these kids get the opportunity to experience doubt, to struggle through it, and to find a renewed and stronger faith in the Gospel's real message: The Kingdom of God is at hand, repent and be saved.
Turn towards God by your own free choice, and he'll welcome you with open arms.
|
Your experience with the Jesuits sounds very similar to my own. Their philosophy seemed to be based on a questioning of faith, even at the expense of losing some of those Catholics in their charge. My school was known for taking in devout Catholic boys and producing devout Catholic men and ardent atheist men. If I had a son, I would send him to a Jesuit school in a heartbeart. I have immense respect for the Jesuits.
Back on topic: I haven't seen the movie - only a sensationalistic trailer. So, I'm hesitant to draw any conclusions. However, I agree with SirLance. In my opinion, the opportunity to question your faith is essential to long-term spiritual development.