wow.... these are both very different - for the first one, the first seven stanzas seem to contrast with the rest of the poem - it made me wonder if maybe they'd be better off seperate? The second one is good, but to me, it felt awkward. If maybe every stanza started with "She _____" and then the rest was without, it might change the flow a little.
So to answer your question, I think the first one spoke to me more
Very lyrical, I kept finding a beat to fit the words. Nice job!