What Halx said. I am NOT the proud owner of a TL, but I sure as hell wish I was
I've driven all 4 of these cars and the TL has the best blend of performance vs luxury. Sure the G35 is faster, but not by much at all, and I don't think the extra speed makes up for the drop in refinement. The EVO should only be bought by people who want to pretend to be rally racers - not people who care about things like a nice ride, comfortable interior, etc. It's a GREAT car from a pure performance standpoint, but when you have that much performance with considerably-below-ferrari pricing, you sacrifice comfort. Possibly reliability too, although the car's just too new for anyone to know at this point.
The Legacy sucks. One of my station's competitors runs them as their news vehicles, and I hear nothing but bitching from their photographers about how bad the ride is, how crappy the power is, how crappy the interior, etc. I've looked 'em over (both the news and the regular versions) and have been totally unimpressed.