I know I am not going to be much help, but you are from Chico!
I go to school there! Okay, now with that out of the way....
There won't ever be anyone that makes you feel like your old boyfriend, and thats okay. Every new relationship will be different, and make you feel different. You just need to find someone that makes you feel even better than your old boyfriend. It is hard to move on, and you will always have them with you in one way or another, but time will heal your wounds.