Growing Meat in Test Tubes...
 

Full story

What are the ethical implications of "growing" meat without actually creating or destroying animals? Is this an animal rights activist's dream come true?

I wish the article explained a little bit more indepth the process of "extracting" the original cells from the animals. Not only that, but how it is "grown". I suppose these questions are the primary source of all the ethical issues that I'm sure are flying around on this issue. The people they interviewed seemed to oppose it because the end product is "a lump of meat that had been pumped full of chemicals", though the article never explicitly states that's how the technology works. I'm sure chemicals are involved, but which ones? Are they "pumped" into the meat? It sounds like it might work in the same manner as skin grafting or other similar technologies. If so, would the same people that wouldn't eat this meat refuse to recieve skin grafts?

It seems to me like in the long run, it would be a good thing if all of their claims are true. If proven safe, I don't think I would have a problem eating artificially cultivated meat. On the other hand, I don't know much about it. Then again, I try to remain ignorant about what they do to produce meat from livestock -- ask any vegan and they will probably tell you horrible things about how meat products are "created". Don't like it? Then don't eat it.

The real question is, how does it taste?
:D

You might laugh but my main concern is, I do not think it would be kosher.

I think this would be great. Especially considering how much energy is gone to waste on the count of producing real meat and the such. It'll be interesting to see where technology will take this.

Dream come true? Isn't it a vegan nightmare?

New T-shirt:
Meat has(ve?) feelings too.

Given that many (not all) vegetarians and vegans are also openly anti-science/anti-technology, especially when it comes to food, I'm not sure how big of an impact this would have on that particular community. Also, who's willing to wager that this 'synthetic meat' tastes very....erm...synthetic? At least for the first few years, until they perfect the techniques.

This is all very interesting, but I don't imagine that this will be an easy sell.

My wife, a vegitarian, suggested that on first glance it takes care of her concerns about eating meat. She wanted more information though.

Don't forget the thread from a month ago, Meat Grown in a Lab, Would you Eat it??, for further background.
It all depends on the activist and their personal reasons, as well as the details behind how the meat is made. I read an excelent scifi story by Harry Turtledove, about a genetically modified breed of pig that didn't have cloven hooves... and, was it Kosher?

Sounds like a competitor of spam. I wonder how it would taste? Would it really be considered beef or chicken anymore? I don't think it would do very well. People enjoy eating other animals too much.

I guarantee it tastes like shit.

This is the stuff that will go into all those nasty processed things like chicken 'shapes' or burgers, or hot-dogs. If they can replace all that 'mechanically reclaimed' meat with something equally vile, but without using up so much space, then I'm all for it. I still want eat the stuff, but I'll be happier knowing that the people in McDonald's are chowing down to something slightly less unpleasant than they are at the moment.

I agree. I would probably enjoy eating "grown meat" in hotdogs than the crap they put in them now.

If they can tailor the taste and scale the process it'd do away with huge waste (land/materials/polution) in commercial animal industries. That's completely ignoring ethical questions.

I'm all for it, I just wonder about the economics. The stuff we get in hotdogs is largely scraps. Using "grown meat" will be a tough sell. It won't be cheap initially, so why will packagers change. It'll be a more expensive component, it'll costs more to sell, and it canibalizes their profitable lines?

Time for a Ben & Jerry Meat flavor? <img src="http://www.tfproject.org/tfp/images/smilies/hmmm.gif"> ptui! Really, alternate marketers may be its only hope.

I remember hearing all about vast 'flavouring' plants that already impart meaty flavours to the slurry that gets pressure-washed off animal carcasses before it goes into processed foods, so putting vat-grown meat through the same process doesn't seem problematic at all.

Can someone tell me what the 'ethical question' about this is - because I see absolutely none whatsoever.

Is it better to kill fewer animals for food? Beyond PETA concerns we have economic impact on food industry, its communities, and those that support it. The evolve-or-die card is always available, but look at what happened with tobacco.

Again, I'd give it a try and hope for the best but I have relatives who won't microwave their food for fear of eating radiation.

If it came from a dead animal, raise an animal, keep it living healthily, then let it die of old age, and then BAM - You've got your animal to grow the meat from. It was gonna die anyway and it lived a good life.

Here's a plant for you: Givaudan . I've done some work at one of their plants. The whole place smells of cooked meat, and there is no meat there. It's creepy.

Did you check the attic?


;)

If the meat were produced without a mind to gather conciousness, I cannot blatantly oppose its production. But given other options, I would not personally partake.

I'v always found it funny when people say stuff like "it tastes like shit" or like locobot said "I guarantee it tastes like shit.".. Locobot can you answer me exactly how you know what shit tastes like?

I'll assume that (once the process is perfected) the prime rib will taste like prime rib and the pork chop will taste like a pork chop. And if this is the case, and it is cheaper than the "old kind of meat" (that comes from actual animals) I'll eat it every day.

Comparable quality and price is what it comes down to for me.

a) There should be no moral issues here...


b) I'd imagine it'd taste almost exactly the same for two reasons... they couldn't sell it if it didn't, and it's being grown from muscle tissue... which is what meat IS. *boggle* If the meat is made out of actual meat, how would it not taste like meat?


c) I'd think it'd be cheaper. You don't have farmers to pay, cattle to buy, raise, feed and slaughter. You just have labs full of meat machines. *shrug*


As for PETA and Vegans... who cares? If they eat it, great... if they don't... more for me! Yummy tube steak. Oh wait... Eeeewwww!!!