Vales419

Hey all,

Well my wife and I saw HP3 last night at a midnight show and it was sold out. Of being a fan of the books and first two movies, are hopes for the third was quite high.

I have to say that we were very dissapointed...

The acting of kids were great,the FX where extremely cool (hippogriff was awesome), but it seemed that the director jumped all over, the movie just did not flow. They were some major differences between the book and the movie and the movie seemed like it was rushed to be released.

When we were walking out of the theater, many people were talking that that they didn't like it and hopefully they will not make the same mistakes for the rest of the series.

Some say yeah, I am glad they made some differences between the book and the movie, but others like myself, it should had been more faithful to the book...

2.5/5.0

How about you?

Thanks for reading,

V.

__________________
"Here's ten bucks, bring me the head of Barry Manilow" --Dr. Denis Leary

Peryn

Little sister and family are going to see it tonight. Should be fun. It really saddens me to see people change the plot from the book. And as the books keep getting longer, if i remembr right this movie is supposed to be shorter too.

The book, while nothing spectacular, was fun. Thats about all the hope i have for this movie... it should be fun.

__________________
Dont cry kid, It's not your fault you suck.

Nimbletoe

I liked it a lot. Just as good as the other two movies, but I didn't read the books. I'm going to wait to read them until after all the movies come out, that way I can enjoy both, rather than just enjoying the book and be like "why is the movie different?".

__________________
Go Pistons!

gump

just got back from watching it...

over all i thought was good and the effects where great. buckbeat was incredible along with the dementors. i give it 9.5

Amethyst

My husband and daughters are on there way to the theater's right now to watch it. And I get stuck going to my sisters graduation. I hope to rent it though.

Lasereth

It's getting way better reviews than the first two movies. Roger Ebert gave it 3.5 stars out of 4. He believes that it doesn't deserve 4 stars because some people that haven't read the books (and some younger people that have) may get confused during the movie. That's probably the jumping-around aspect you're talking about. 3.5 stars is still an incredible score, though!

Me and my girlfriend are seeing it tomorrow. I can't wait!

-Lasereth

__________________
"A Darwinian attacks his theory, seeking to find flaws. An ID believer defends his theory, seeking to conceal flaws." -Roger Ebert

Ace_O_Spades

I learned through watching the lord of the rings movies not to care when they stray from the book

some things just dont translate, and some things the director feels he needs to change in order to make it flow better in film form... you can't get caught up on changes... or you will end up being disappointed

after getting over the changes, two towers is my favorite of the three (well... i havent seen the third extended yet... so we'll see)

but im getting off topic... so yeah im gonna stop now

__________________
Feh.

bltzkriegmcanon

Geez, the movie's gonna be out longer than just this weekend. You shouldn't have any trouble catching it past this week. Hell, my city's got at least 5 seperate theaters (in the same building) showing it this weekend. Even if the count of theaters were to decrease by one per week, you mean to tell me that, if missing it in the first week, I stand no chance of seeing it in the next month. I'm sorry, but there's no way that I would ever let my life get so filled and complicated that I couldn't take a Saturday or any night of the week to go see a movie. Sorry. Not an attack on you, just stating my surprise.

Absolutely. The Spoiler: time-travel portion of the book can lose anybody who doesn't analyze it carefully. Hell, some of the people reviewing get the details confused.

Take for example, Rex Reed's review. He begins with this verbal assault on which, most people (89% of those who review on Rottentomatoes.com can't be wrong!) found the movie to be an enticing tale with a good plot, first class acting, and extremely good special effects. Beyond that, what can one want from a movie, apparently Reed must want something else.

I just disagree with him on this. It's called "suspension of disbelief", you ass. If he took a few minutes to stop projecting the world around him onto his opinions of the movie, maybe he wouldn't have not liked it so much.

Just what the hell is that?!? That's not even close to what the book has intended it's called a time-turner, pay a-fucking-ttention!!

Annnnnnngt, wrong, bitch. That's not even close. Not even remarkably within 100 miles of what was going on.

Well, Jesus! With all the incorrect plot details he spurned out, I don't think we have to worry about that!

__________________
What do you say to one last showdown?
- Ocelot, Metal Gear Solid 3

The password is "Who are the Patriots?" and "La-Li-Lu-Le-Lo." "La-Li-Lu-Le-Lo." Gotcha.
- The Colonel and Snake, Metal Gear Solid 3

Ace_O_Spades

some movie reviewers just dont have a clue at all

__________________
Feh.

Fremen

I can't wait for HPatPoA on dvd.
(no theaters for me)

Is this the same Rex Reed that had a cameo in Superman: The Movie?

__________________
Google

Mr.Deflok

bltzkriegmcanon, I cry with you... my God... that person is the reason why the term Ass-hat was invented, Jesus...

Lacjack

just saw the movie and got to saw it was amazing, probably the best of the three .

ironchef82

I say it was definitely the best of the three. It just seemed a lot more 'mature' of a movie. I really liked all of the transitions between scenes, cinematography, etc. Graphics and fx were really well done as well.

Speed_Gibson

saw the trailer today before thoroughly enjoying Shrek 2 and would still prefer to laugh/grimace through Plan 9 from Outer Space again before I watch this.

__________________
Started talking to yourself I see.
Yes, it's the only way I can be certain of an intelligent conversation.

Black Adder

Vilkata

I saw it tonight
I liked the movie except for the way they altered the ending from the book. But oh well, shit happens.

__________________
LOL KEEKLES

-Ever-

Saw it tonight with my girlfriend. I havn't read any of the books and I didn't see the second of the films. However I enjoyed this film a lot. I guess I had really low hopes so it sufficed just fine. The story did seem to jump around though, especially nearing the end. Seemed desperate to me for a bit.

-T

__________________
Embracing the goddess energy within yourselves will bring all of you to a new understanding and valuing of life. A vision that inspires you to live and love on planet Earth. Like a priceless jewel buried in dark layers of soil and stone, Earth radiates her brilliant beauty into the caverns of space and time. Perhaps you are aware of those who watch over your home And experience of this place to visit and play with reality. You are becoming aware of yourself as a gamemaster...
--Acknowledge your weaknesses--

Cynthetiq

I saw it as a screener on Thursday night.

I was underwhelmed. It was a good movie, entertaining, but not memorable in anyway IMHO just like the 3 books put together as I read them one right after the other, I found that this was only eh.

Visually it does not disappoint, and the movie had good pacing and screenplay. The marauders map was very very cool, and the credits at the end were worth staying for just to watch the feet walk about, and the very very ending, with HP saying something....

__________________
I don't care if you are black, white, purple, green, Chinese, Japanese, Korean, hippie, cop, bum, admin, user, English, Irish, French, Catholic, Protestant, Jewish, Buddhist, Muslim, indian, cowboy, tall, short, fat, skinny, emo, punk, mod, rocker, straight, gay, lesbian, jock, nerd, geek, Democrat, Republican, Libertarian, Independent, driver, pedestrian, or bicyclist, either you're an asshole or you're not.

Lasereth

I saw it today. What a great movie! I agree with Roger Ebert, though...those that haven't read the books will be incredibly confused. Cuaron left out a bunch of the book's main plot to make the movie shorter. If you haven't read the book, prepare to have someone who has explain after the movie is over.

As for the directing and acting...superb. These actors are getting better, and that's saying a lot!

-Lasereth

__________________
"A Darwinian attacks his theory, seeking to find flaws. An ID believer defends his theory, seeking to conceal flaws." -Roger Ebert

bltzkriegmcanon

Holy Jesus. I just got back from watching it tonight. A-fucking-mazing. This movie was better than the first 2 movies or books [b]combined[\b]. Damn, this is, for me, the best movie of the summer, easily. I can say with no ego that is the best of the Potter movies. Hands down. And I don't just mean the first 3, I mean of all 7 or possibly 8. This movie puts the first 2 to fucking shame. That's how good it is. Those first two can't hold a damn candle to this one. If I ever meet Cuaron, I'll skip shaking his hand and go straight to shaking his dick. Incredible. Everything about this movie captures the precise spirit of the book. Not every detail is captured, and that's no complaint. There are certain things in the book that are too complicated or not important enough that I think, for time's sake, can be left out.

**SPOILER ALERT FROM THIS POINT FORWARD**

Spoiler: Things like Snape hating Lupin and wanting to kill Sirius as 1) glory-seeking and 2)revenge for the shit that he pulled on him at Hogwarts back in the day. Or how Hermione came across Crookshanks, and why Crookshanks was always after Scabbers (Pettigrew), and how Crookshanks was in league with Black from the start.

While these events would have made the story perhaps even easier to grasp for those who haven't read the books, I still believe that Cuaron's storytelling abilities and directorial style enable him to make the story palatable, followable and damn well enjoyable.

I'm not the kind of guy who laughs or openly smiles during movies. I tend to internalize what I experience during the movie and then express my feelings on it afterwards. In the case of this movie, I was grinning almost the entire time. Everything about this movie tells me that it's going to be THE best movie that comes out this summer, and probably the best movie of the entire Potter series. That's not me bashing the first 2 movies, because they, in their own way, were good movies, but still, I say that those 2 movies just cannot, in any way, shape, or form come close to the quality that is The Prisoner of Azkaban. Damn.

The acting in this movie was far, far superior to the previous movies. The young people playing the roles of the main characters, and even side characters have made tremendous strides in their acting abilites.

The special effects in this movie are spectacular. Everything about the effects in this movie are done so subtly that there's never an obvious point where graphics are being showcased just for the sake of graphics, as is often the case in many big budget fantasy/sci-fi films. Cuaron, once again, influenced this process, making every effect apparent enough so that they are noticed, but they are not so apparent that they draw undue attention to themselves. That is the intention of anything in film however, and it is sad that people in the special effects field tend to forget that. However, things like magic, creatures, and even the Knight Bus are done effortlessly by Cuaron's crew, delivering just the effect that one would desire to see from a movie about magic. The effects are never so outrageous that one thinks "WOW!!! These are good graphics! So where's the real movie?" No. This is not the case with Azkaban.

All in all, if you can't tell by the length of my post and it's contents, I really, really enjoyed this movie, and not only was it "awesome" but it was "damn good" as well. Words like "awesome" are usually reserved for movies like The Day After Tomorrow and Spider-Man, which contain sequences that are just that, "awesome sequences", but these do not necessarily construct a "good" movie.

However, in the case of Azkaban, there are "awesome" effects, and "awesome" sequences, such as the Spoiler: dementor scene down by the lake where Harry repels them, the entire thing with the stag, the werewolf, all of it. But these effects are not so much that they overwhelm the content of the movie. Therefore, this is a movie that is a rare case indeed, in which it is both "awesome" and "good" in the same breath.

My final score: 10/10. Go see it, whether or not you've read the books is meaningless, you will most likely enjoy this film, and I mean that at least 90% of the time, this movie will be THOUROUGHLY enjoyable.

__________________
What do you say to one last showdown?
- Ocelot, Metal Gear Solid 3

The password is "Who are the Patriots?" and "La-Li-Lu-Le-Lo." "La-Li-Lu-Le-Lo." Gotcha.
- The Colonel and Snake, Metal Gear Solid 3

Jrock

I saw it tonight. I'm not bothered by the changes. Some things work on the page that don't work well on film. Also, if there were no changes, we'd have at least a five hour movie. A few things could have been explained better for those who haven't read the book, but those parts were mostly minor details.

I am worried about the conversion of the rest of the series from book to movie. Book four is almost as long as the entire Lord of the Rings trilogy, which was three three hour movies and still left parts out. It is not at all possible to condense it down into one movie and do the book any justice.

warrrreagl

My wife saw it tonight and loved it. Neither of us has read any of the books.

As for Rex Reed, I've been convinced for a number of years that movie reviewers cannot physically see every movie in its entirety, therefore they base their reviews on info gathered from other sources (and sometimes they're glaringly wrong).

__________________
Living is easy with eyes closed.

Arc101

Not impressed. I don't care that the film is different from the book, as long as it is a good film. This isn't, I thought it dragged a lot and was quite boring. Did like the special effects. I would give this 4/10

Sparhawk

Boring and anti-climactic. The best part of this series is the world that JK Rowling created, and it sure is fun getting to see more of it, but the plot in this one was tedious and dull.

The first two were much better.

__________________
"In Iraq, no doubt about it, it's tough. It's hard work. It's incredibly hard. It's - and it's hard work. I understand how hard it is. I get the casualty reports every day. I see on the TV screens how hard it is. But it's necessary work. We're making progress. It is hard work."

Peryn

Ughh... saw it the other night, but haven't had time to post.

Thouroughly dissapointed. I wasn't expecting much out of the movie... just to have a little fun with it. And i was let down even still.

I really didn't like how he changed around the geography of the school, at least from what i remember of the previous 2 movies. The whomping willow is now down some hillside tucked away, where in teh second movie it was surrounded by a green area near the fron of the school when the boys crashed in it. And Hagrids hut is now moved down a cliff into the middle of nowhere, clearly not near where it was in the first 2 movies.

As for the ending, i was reasonably impresed. Given how little time they put into showing the main plot, i thought they wrapped it up reasonably well.

Also, the third book was one of my most favorites of the series. It was a great mystery novel. A fun Who-dun-it book, whereas most of the rest of them were action/adventure type stories. The movie didn't portray that to me at all. I thought tehy needed to spend less time on scenes such as the Knight Bus, which has no real importance to the storyline, and spend more time on the plot and mystery aspect of it. I never once felt as if Harry was being hunted. Another run-in with Black or the dog and i would have.

Lastly, the "magic" the first two movies had. They were fun, magical movies. And not just in that there was a lot of spells, but the atmosphere. Granted, harrys life and part in this book is kind of dark, but with all the scenes in teh school, it never once felt magical to me.

They skipped through so many important story events that i found myself glad i had read the book, or i would have been thouroughly confused as to the plot of this film. I felt it had no real depth to it. There was tremendous growth of the character in teh book, yet in the movie there was very little character development throughout the school year.


Well, with all the ranting over, it still wasn't horrible. The visual effects and acting were far superior to the other 2. Great actors for Trewlauny (sp?), Black, and Lupin (even though he looked too...british... for my tastes). The new Dumbledore actor looked like he had potential to the perfect actor for the role, but was never given the chance to show it.

All in all 2.5/5 ... maybe a 3/5 if im in a good mood.

__________________
Dont cry kid, It's not your fault you suck.

philosopherking

Just saw it last night, and I must say it is definitly my favorite of the three. Cuaron did an excellent job directing and getting the actors to actually do some acting. As for the comments about people not reading the books getting confused by the plot, I had no problem with it. I dunno, maybe it's my experience trying to figure out movies such as Mullholland Drive, but I didn't find it confusing in the least, and I've never touched a Potter book. I also enjoyed the little homage to Y Tu Mama Tambien, I couldn't help but laugh out loud at that in the theatre, I think I got several weird looks. Overall great film, 4 stars.

Peryn

Just reminded me... i loved them throwing in a little reference to Steven Hawking near the beginning. The theatre kinda stayed silent, and I was just busting up.

__________________
Dont cry kid, It's not your fault you suck.

gnort

eh, it was ok. Nothing great. The visuals in the movie were the best part imo. I would give it around a 2-2.5/5 only because my friend and I had a blast making comments throughout.

__________________
You had me at Qapla'

ShaniFaye

I am a new fan of HP, my fiance LOVES the books and finally convinced me to read them and see the first two movies...in the last 7 days I have read the 1st two books, started the 3rd and have seen all 3 movies, whew....I will never understand people who go to a movie expecting it to be exactly like the book...I dont honestly think I can come up with ONE book turned movie where the movie followed the book 100%...

Having seen all three movies back to back I have to say I enjoyed the 3rd one MUCH more...the other movies to me seemed more disjointed than the new one...I loved the outside shots of #3 (since it was filmed in the scottish highlands, which is one of my favorite places in the world).

I do think they might have expanded on the explanations of a few things more but on the whole if I rate it agains the other two I give it a 10/10

__________________
I want the diabetic plan that comes with rollover carbs. I dont like the unused one expiring at midnite!!

Nefir

I'm a huge Potter fan, and having pretty much memorized the plot details of each book (yea, I've read them all quite a few more times than just once ), I can say that this movie can be enjoyed to a much greater extent if you've read the book and can suspend your disbelief, and let your imagination fill in the missing plot pieces - after all, they are all there, just not shown in the movie!

I thoroughly enjoyed it, but at the same time did notice plenty of missing or oversimplified parts, which did not bother me at all. The special effects were top-notch, and the new Dumbledore is perfect. I can't wait for the DVD!

PS: For those who never read PoA - I consider this THE BEST Potter book out there, so use this opportunity to start reading

__________________
You do not use a Macintosh, instead you use a Tandy
Kompressor break your glowstick, Kompressor eat your candy
Kompressor open jaws, Kompressor release ants
Kompressor watch you scream, Because Kompressor does not dance

Mehoni

Pfft.. fifth book, fifth book!

PoA premieres in two days, but I have my ways. I'll be seeing it tonight.

__________________
There seem to be countless rituals and cultural beliefs designed to alleviate their fear of a simple biological truth - all organisms eventually perish.

Fremen

My favorite so far is number four, The Goblet of Fire.

__________________
Google

omid

can't wait for the fourth/fifth movies. wow

__________________
Kick butt buzz-cut dickheads who didn't like what I said.
The good times are killing me.
Jaws clenching tight we talked all night, oh but what the hell did we say?
The good times are killing me.

mr sticky

I'm just pretty much dittoing everthing Peryn said.

Almost down to the last syllable...damn, that's really weird for me!

__________________
The sad thing is... as you get older you come to realize that you don't so much pilot your life, as you just try to hold on, in a screaming, defiant ball of white-knuckle anxious fury

frankgrimes

I've enjoyed all the movies, but this one was my favorite, probably because, like Nefir, the third book was my favorite. Though a significant amount of business is left out of the film, the particulars are there and put together in a coherant and visually beautiful way. - I'm happy...

evilbeefchan

I liked it alot. I honestly don't think it "jumped around." It all built up to a nice ending as well. I also enjoyed it because there were actual character growth. It wasn't another episode of "crazy harry and his magical friends adventure hour."

pocon1

I like them all. I think Columbus did a good job creating the fantasy and the ambience of the place, and I think cuaron did a good job with the actors. I liked Lupin, I want to see more of Gary Oldman as Black, and I liked the new dumbledore. I must admit, I had a little tear in my eye when Harry cast "EXPECTO PATRONUM!"

Mehoni

Okay, now I've seen it. It was too fast IMO. I felt stressed watching it.

__________________
There seem to be countless rituals and cultural beliefs designed to alleviate their fear of a simple biological truth - all organisms eventually perish.

onetime2

Saw it last night. It was at least as good as the other two. I haven't read the books so staying true to them doesn't matter to me.

Overall an excellent movie well worth the $30 we spent to see it.

__________________
Strive to be more curious than ignorant.

Maleigh99

I saw it the other night, and I too felt it a bit rushed. Maybe it's because this was my fav HP book, and I just wanted more. Visually, it was better than the first two. I think I just need to see it again. Can't wait until it comes out on DVD!

sinjien

I must say this: It was without a doubt the best of the three. And it gave me goose bumps watching it on IMAX!!! Trust me - it is a totally different experience viewing this movie on an IMAX screen. Its like comparing VHS in analog sound to HD progressive scan DVD with 7.1 THX digital. To those of you who understand (and those who just loved the movie) go find an IMAX screen right now. Just a small warning: it was a little pricy. I live near San Francisco and tickets are usually 8-9 bucks. But IMAX per person is now $14!!! Yeah it sucks....but the movie still rocked.