thinktank

http://democracyforvirginia.typepad....ative_sen.html
I know many of you are farkers too, so you may have caught this, but i was blown when i saw it. I dont even like America, why cant they leave their laws off our bodies?

Coppertop

That's a horribly misleading thread title. In fact, it's downright wrong. The article says not reporting miscarriages within 12 hours would be illegal. There is a difference.

tecoyah

There is indeed a difference. But the law is still an invasion of privacy that I personally find unacceptable. It is not at all suprising though, in the current climate this country enjoys.

__________________
Holding onto anger is like grasping a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else; you are the one who gets burned. - Buddha

john_713

Either way in all that trauma forgetting to report it is hardly a punishable offence. They might as well be illegal 12 hours isn't a long time really.

Coppertop

Yes, it is indeed invasive. I understand why it might be necessary however. Yes, it seems insensitive, but that's our government for you. No real way to tip toe around something so sensitive.

thinktank

I don’t think a semantics argument changes the completely god awful implications. that’s an evil suggestion, that only some government greedhead would even conceive of. The way things snowball anymore it'll take two month until you've got to call the police every time you go to the bathroom. I'll keep my right to privacy, thank you very much.

brianna

I fail to understand why this is any of the government's business.

Carno

It's not semantics, it's right and wrong. The thread title is wrong and should be changed.

It's a stupid law though. It never ceases to amaze me the terrible laws people put into place.

Coppertop

What, exactly, is an evil suggestion?

Coppertop

And yes, disposing of human remains properly is the government's business. Sounds cold, I know. Believe me when I say I am in a position to know.

thinktank

Making it so that if my girlfriend had a miscarriage that she would have to call some faceless Bureaucrat? Thats some pretty evil stuff, friend.

maleficent

I'd really love to see a less one-sided reference to this law -- but alas - -searching on HB1677, nothing except Democracy for Virginia shows up


Can any other sources for this be provided... Maybe giving a less emotional accouting of the law... Friends making hot cocoa does nothing to sway my opinion...

__________________

phredgreen

thread title changed.


having recently moved to virginia, this is just another not-suprise... shortly after i got out here they passed a law that basically removed any rights domestic partners had... they forbade them from owning property, having rights to the other's children, even power of attourney.

this state is a fucked up repugnant place full of backward people who could, in my opinion, all die to the betterment of humanity as a whole. i'm here because the wife is going to school here. as soon as that's done, we're leaving, plain and simple. i refuse to voluntarily live in such a backwards place. the problem is that much of the nation is slowly turning the same way under the guise of religious enlightenment.

__________________
My country is the world, and my religion is to do good.
- Thomas Paine

phredgreen

maleficient: you can find the writeup here:

http://leg1.state.va.us/cgi-bin/legp...051+ful+HB1677

the exerpt in question:

__________________
My country is the world, and my religion is to do good.
- Thomas Paine

Coppertop

Evil? Hardly. Insensitive? Yes.

I didn't see where it said the mother had to personally report it. Perhaps a friend, relative or neighbor could do it? Just a thought. But this is an emotional issue, so I'm really not surprised at people's reactions.

The_wall

Wow this has to be a joke. Do you think this will pass?

__________________
"We do what we like and we like what we do!"~andrew Wk

Procrastinate now, don't put off to the last minute.

thinktank

I'll tell you coppertop, i attempt to incite. I'm tired of the apathy from which so many Americans suffer. You're given the right to a difference of opinion in this country, but so few take advantage of it. I see this as a kick to the pants of human rights, so i'll spread the word and upset as many people as i can with it. I never said i was right or that anyone had to agree with me, just that i consider it to be villainy. Pardon my exaggerations, but that’s all that they are, emotional outburts from a fed-up kid who reads the news too often.

Arroe

If someone dies you report it to the police. Why can't you report a miscarriage? It's to make sure that it wasn't illegally aborted. It only would protect the mother and child. Sure, I see how after having a misscarriage is tramatizing, but a phone call made by a spouse or friend on behalf of the woman would most likely be acceptable and should not be that big of a deal.

hunnychile

It's wrong and no one business except the mothers. Period.

__________________
"I need compassion, understanding and chocolate." - NJB

pinoychink790

yeah, women should have the right to have secrets and stuff

Grasshopper Green

Besides this not being the governments business, should this law pass it could possibly prevent women from seeking proper prenatal care. Would the doctor be required to pass on the information if she chose not to? Would a woman choose not to have medical care for her pregnancy to prevent this? This is just too intrusive for my taste.

hunnychile

Without secrets women just survive....and barely.

__________________
"I need compassion, understanding and chocolate." - NJB

maleficent

How come women's groups and the ACLU don't have this front and center in the media? Is the bill that buried that it's escaped notice, or is more being read into that is really there. If anything, women's groups, especially NARAL, would be most interested in this law because what's the next step, a woman has an abortion, then has to call the police department and report herself?

Currently, if the miscarriage occurs in the presence of a doctor (Do midwives count as a healthcare professional) does the miscarraige still get reported, what if the woman has an abortion, does that get reported to the fetal death bureau? Why shouldn't it be the responsibility of the doctor to report it? Since numbers of abortions yearly get recorded, I'd imagine that someone is reporting them, and surely not the woman.

__________________

AquaFox

what good does this law have at all??


if they don't track babies from conception, why do they need to know when they die???

while there at it, they should require us to have a permit each time we have sex!

__________________


...AquaFox...

snowy

This is ridiculous, pure and simple. Why do miscarriages need to be included in vital statistics? What could possibly be so important about those vital statistics that the mother needs to report WITHIN 12 HOURS? Give me a break.

This is information a woman should be allowed to keep to herself.

__________________
If I am not better, at least I am different. --Jean-Jacques Rousseau

tecoyah

Yeah....lets just get 30% of pregnant women to give a call and tell some pencil pusher "oh, by the way....I lost my baby today".

I dont know why....but this really pisses me off.

Here is a little info to show the frequency of occurance:


As many as 30 percent of all pregnancies end in miscarriage, half of them before the woman even realizes she is pregnant. Fortunately, most women who miscarry, even more than once, can become pregnant again and give birth to a healthy baby. If you have had a miscarriage and want to try again, work with your doctor to learn the reason for the loss and to plan future pregnancies. Closely monitored pregnancies are especially important for women who have miscarried.

Your doctor may refer to a miscarriage as a “spontaneous abortion,” since “abortion” is the medical term for any interrupted pregnancy. A miscarriage, or spontaneous abortion, is the loss of a pregnancy before the fetus can survive outside the womb, usually within the first 20 weeks.

__________________
Holding onto anger is like grasping a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else; you are the one who gets burned. - Buddha

MSD

The government has no reason to need this information, and therefore should not be permitted to pass a law requiring the reporting of this information.

side note, this is from the article:
So it's perfectly fine to have sex with your child or grandchild if they're older than 15? I'm going to side with phred on this one.

brianna

you know this law makes no provision for babies lost very early in the pregnancy when many women don't even know the've been pregnant. additionally, the law requires that the baby's gender be reported which would not be possible for early pregnancies. ridiculous.

gondath

I second this opinion. I don't see why this is such a big deal. Deaths should always be reported. The only people who wouldn't want to report it are those who have something to hide.

john_713

I see your point but it is a very sensitive matter and something the woman should be allowed to keep private. I fail to see the point in 'illegal' abortions. It should also be the womans choice if she goes ahead with it or not. If she has been forced to abort her baby then she should go to the police anyway.

tecoyah

So....out of curiousity. Who gets to decide the legalities of when a group of cells becomes human....and therefore the mother committed manslaughter by falling down the stairs. Do we decide these cells are Human the scientific way (when they form a brain capable of creating waves that bear some resemblence to human thought)?
Or do we decide the religious way (when sperm meets egg)?
Once we decide, what sentencing guidelines would we place on a woman who has an accident, that could have been prevented. Six months in prison sound good? How about Nine months....seems fitting. She will need a good lawyer as well...to prove it was an accident, and that she did not throw herself down the stairs to Kill her child.

Fuck that.....Just dont get pregnant, Abstinence is best anyway.....isn't it?

__________________
Holding onto anger is like grasping a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else; you are the one who gets burned. - Buddha

ObieX

Government should have NO ROLE in this WHAT-SO-EVER. <-- the previous statement goes for MANY things.

__________________
We Must Dissent.

gondath

Again, I don't see the big need for secrecy in a society that doesn't place much value on the life of an unborn child in the first place. I repeat, what do they have to hide? I don't much care if a prison term is included in the penalty, though I seriously doubt that it would be. Towards the issue of determining humanity. Here's a simple test: is the woman pregnant? If yes, then she is carrying a human. If you can prove to me she is carrying something else, then yes, she should keep that a secret.

tecoyah

I Doubt very much I could prove to you that a group of cells is not a human, as this is a sometimes religious debate. But I will say it has been proven to "Me" that it takes more than a fertilized egg to create a human. And we would therefore carry a very different understanding of the "realities" in this debate.

__________________
Holding onto anger is like grasping a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else; you are the one who gets burned. - Buddha

munchen

this may have already been assumed but does anyone see this as framework to to overturn Roe v. Wade? thats the only reason i can find for this law. i know bush and co. are religious ideologs and that there are many repulicans that want this overturned. since they control so much of the government now do you think they could be aiming for this?

__________________
"Love is a perky elf dancing a merry little jig and then suddenly he turns on you with a miniature machine gun" -Matt Groening

SVT01Cobra

Ugh...that makes me sick.

What's sad is that people will probably vote, not even knowing what it does.

MSD

I fully agree with this.

Bryndian_Dhai

Actually, when the child is a blood relative, it falls into a whole new class of criminal act, which also forbids marriage to a blood relative. That's the reason for the exception in that particular law.

As for the topic at hand... I had a miscarriage at 13 weeks. I have, to this day, not "reported" it to anyone. I include it in my medical history by simply saying that I have had two interrupted pregnancies. My miscarriage happened in my home. Sorry if this seems harsh, but I flushed the detritus from the miscarriage (bloody tissue... if there was a fetus in there, I didn't see it) down the toilet just like I do menstrual discharge.

It was nobody's business but mine, and still isn't. If I choose to share it, it's my business.

The only reason I can see behind such a law is to track women who have had interrupted pregnancies, in preparation to begin to require that women who have had abortions report those procedures as well, which as of now are protected by law as confidential.

The only way to keep things like this from happening isn't by moving away, its by fighting each and every attempt to take a liberty away. Stand up and be heard. They do these things because they can, because the majority of Americans don't take an interest in the workings of the government and don't notice the slow, steady process by which our liberties are being stripped from us.

__________________
“When facism comes to America it will be wrapped in the flag and carrying a cross.”
~Sinclair Lewis

bad jane

why would a woman have to have "something to hide" to be against reporting this? i'm an adult and if i were pregnant it would be noone's business but mine and the people i chose to share it with.

and sorry, but you couldn't get someone else to make this call for you. did you read all that you have to report? maybe a husband could make the call--but not in every case. how many husbands know their wives medical history in detail? he may have a big picture, but does he know the dates of her last period? does he know how many dr visits she's had? does he know about all previous pregnancies and the history of those? i can't think of a single person besides myself, (including my ex husband) who would have all the info they want reported.

and what if the woman hasn't told anyone she's pregnant? it's not uncommon for a woman who's not trying to get pregnant to hold off telling her partner about it. so my dr doesn't know, my partner doesn't know, none of my friends and family know--but i have to share this info with the gov? thanks but no thanks.

i agree with another poster, the only benefit to this law that i can see is that it helps to establish that a miscarriage is the death of a person at any age of gestation. that correlates with getting roe v wade overturned.

while i understand that different people have different views on abortion--we are not just talking about someone who decides they don't want to have a baby. reporting a miscarriage within 12 hours is asking a lot of a woman who's suffered enough imo.

Demeter

Reminiscent of 'The Handmaids Tale' by Margaret Atwood. Any woman with a funtioning womb is turned over to the government to breed for weathy infertile couples. Makes ya think...