optik_nerve

I'm not sure where to put this but if it's in the wrong place feel free to move it.

I saw this video and I couldn't believe my eyes. How could anyone survive?

http://www.kontraband.com/show/show.asp?ID=1489&NSFW=

Not for the weak.

Thoughts anyone?

K-Wise

Hmm either you messed up or I'm stupid. I see HTML Code: and a bar underneath it but nothing else.

Asta!!

__________________
"I love music and it's my parents fault (closing statement)." - Me..quoting myself...from when I said that...On TFP..thats here...Tilted Forum Project

It ain't goodbye, it's see ya later! I'll miss you guys! - Asta!!

optik_nerve

How's that?

:::OshnSoul:::

WTF!!!!!!! Oh my goodness..........I saw it.....kinda wish I didn't.........wow

K-Wise

Holy shit that had to be fake. No fuckin way! I mean shit that was a long fuckin drop for one. Crazy how the dude got up and said "I'm cool dude I'm cool" then saw his hand and all the blood and freaked out and passed out. WTF is that black thing on his head? I mean it's not like something real like that happens with all that blood and then a frame later he's got this black thing on his head where he hit himself and looks to be wearing the same shirt and chain. It looked pretty fuckin real though....I dunno...shit thats fuckin crazy.

Asta!!

__________________
"I love music and it's my parents fault (closing statement)." - Me..quoting myself...from when I said that...On TFP..thats here...Tilted Forum Project

It ain't goodbye, it's see ya later! I'll miss you guys! - Asta!!

Fremen

It's fake. The blood released too weirdly.
If it were real, he wouldn't be up and about like that.

__________________
Google

anleja

I think it's fake. If you watch it slowly, between the part when he hit the wall and the part where the camera pans down to show his body the camera looks as if was turned off and on again. But it DID show him kinda fall off that ledge... maybe they put pillows or something down for his landing, then filmed him laying down a few minutes later.

Alright, I believe it's fake, but I have no clue how they did it.

*edit... definitely fake. I mean, his brains came out! I guess you could still live if it was the part of the brain that only stored phone numbers or the locations of area gas stations, but... hmm... maybe it IS real.

JumpinJesus

What'd they do? Patch him up with road tar?

__________________
"I can normally tell how intelligent a man is by how stupid he thinks I am" - Cormac McCarthy, All The Pretty Horses

MSD

The video cuts when it's pointed at the ground. The shaking camera is an attempt to conceal that fact. It's a whole lot of fake blood.

Journeyman

It cuts when he jumps over, he cuts when he gets dropped, but those are technical items that I have no expertise concerning. What moves me to believe it's fake is that acting.

MacGuyver

Word. Blood doesnt flow that quickly unless you've severed an artery or something, in which case he probably would be dead, or damn near to it.

__________________
We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence then, is not an act, but a habit.
---Aristotle

Deeds, not words, shall speak [for] me.
---John Fletcher

dobster

I thought the release was eye fluid at first.

__________________
sig-na-ture
1. One's name as written by oneself.
2. The act of signing one's name.
3. A distinctive mark, characteristic, or sound indicating identity.

optik_nerve

I actually thought it was fake at first too but man, that is damn good if it is.

*Nikki*

Becareful.......that download contained a virus.

optik_nerve

Did it really? What type?

Munku

Looks very very fake to me. The way they are screaming, then his acting as he comes up saying he's ok. Plus the blood kind of pushed out in waves sort of if you know what I'm saying.

LeviticusMky

Way too fake. Anyone could do that with some willing actors and some fake blood. Not to mention a knowledge of simple video editing.

mrdarcy

[I wouldn’t say:
QUOTE=LeviticusMky]Way too fake. [/QUOTE]

I would just say probably fake.

Actually it’s very well done. The convincing parts are that the story line makes since. This appears to be an accident that can happen and the victim incredibly walks away. Notice the way that the background sound of the traffic remains fluid throughout the places where some claim to be camera cuts. The victim, when he appears at the gate, seems to have real blood and his reaction is understandable and believable.

The action is believable. The trip off of the board does not seem forced or unnatural.

There are no giveaways as to a change in time that would indicate editing. By this I mean no changes in bright sunlight one moment and cloudy the next. No shadows falling in one direction in one scene and falling in another direction a moment later, no breaks in background noise.
All in all, I would give it an B+, perhaps even an A-.

The things that lead me to say fake:

1) The speed and the angle that the victim leaves the board does not seem sufficient to propel him all the way to the other building, more so, it seems like just enough to fall directly into the ally below.

2) The sound that he makes when he hits the wall sounds to me too much like what a foley artist would imagine a body to sound like when it hits a wall. My experience with hitting hard walls is that there is little sound other than my saying “opfffff.” However, the wall looked like wooden sheathing and I have no way of knowing how solid it was. It’s possible that a body thrown against a wall of this kind would make an audible noise, but I don’t think that the noise in the clip accurately captures this sound.

3) The position of the body. We see the victim clutch at the ledge before he falls. This means that the body had very little time to tumble as it fell. The body would then most likely fall feet first facing the building. The body would then fall away from the building backwards and landing face up, or if it had tumbled slightly, fallen on it’s side with the victim raising his arms to protect his head from impact. I cannot picture a scenario which would have the victim face down, parallel to the wall and his arm at his side.

4) The blood. This has already been mentioned several times. Sadly, I have witnessed an accident in which a worker fell off of a scaffolding and hit the marble floor three stories below. Because he had lost his balance and tumbled backwards, his body impacted with his body parallel to the ground and his head taking a direct hit. There was bleeding from the victims ear, but it pooled slowly. Not the intense spurt that appears after a delay like we see in the clip. However, I am not an expert on head injuries and how they bleed, but the way it appears in the clip seems suspicious.

5) The reaction of the others. This fact is the most disturbing of all and does the most to convince me of a fake. The reaction to the blood seems to come too soon, as if it were anticipated. The other reaction “What should we do?” and “We gotta’ get down there” mentioned twice seems too pat. It does not seem realistic to me for someone to see his bud fall to the ground and then say “What should we do?” I can see saying that when you get to the ground and not know how to give assistance, but to be up on the roof and not automatically assume that you’ve got to get to your buddy’s side seems a stretch. The idea of keeping the camera running and pointed in the right direction seems a bit far fetched to me also. I mean, if I fall on my head and have blood spurting out of me like a fire hose, put down the freekin camera and get to me!

6) As far as what I guess is suppose to be brains on the asphalt, well that is so far out there that I don’t even consider it a faux. It seems more like the film makers idea of a joke.

This being said, I still thought it was very well done, was very entertaining, and no, I can’t say with 100% accuracy (other than the stuff on the asphalt) that it was fake.

__________________
[Insert pithy comment here]

anleja

Holy crap, I hope I never see anything like this happen to anyone.

sadistikdreams

You'd see a blood splatter, not a puddle escape from his head.
It's SPLAT!, not ooozeee.

But a convincing video otherwise.

__________________
"Besides the noble art of getting things done, there is the noble art of leaving things undone.
The wisdom of life consists in the elimination of non-essentials."
-Lin Yutang

hearts, by d.a.

Fly

the black thing on his head...... maybe that is the beginning of the video and it housed the fake blood and brains,.....and they just show it at the end.


entertaining none the less

__________________
BASTARD

SterlingStudios

tangledweb

It was definitely a fake but a pretty good overall effort. The blood rushing from under his head was the most obvious touch.

superiorrain

Definitely fake. if you watch it in slow mo you can see him hanging off the edge of the wall with his head above it. Meaning there was no way he could even hit his head.

Funny stuff though.

__________________
"The only way to discover the limits of the possible is to go beyond them into the impossible." - Arthur C. Clarke

dobster

Just watched this with the sound on and in my headphones. You can hear the differnt eq on the different voices as they've been edited and pasted in in the studio. The voices also fade out at one point. Boy, we're killjoys aren't we?!

__________________
sig-na-ture
1. One's name as written by oneself.
2. The act of signing one's name.
3. A distinctive mark, characteristic, or sound indicating identity.

tecoyah

My firewall, anti viral , and zone alarm found no virus...if there is one...it is new.

__________________
Holding onto anger is like grasping a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else; you are the one who gets burned. - Buddha

mrdarcy

I didn't find a virus. But returning to the site several times to review the clip would occasionally trigger an attempt to download some spyware and a browser highjacker

__________________
[Insert pithy comment here]

K-Wise

^ I wish I was smart.

Asta!!

__________________
"I love music and it's my parents fault (closing statement)." - Me..quoting myself...from when I said that...On TFP..thats here...Tilted Forum Project

It ain't goodbye, it's see ya later! I'll miss you guys! - Asta!!

bundy

to the great man who made this fine piece of cinematic brilliance,

sir, i salute you. you are indeed a fine young visionary who seriously needs a wider stage on which to perform your art. one day i too hope to try and emulate the work of such masters as Johnny Knoxville and Steve-O by skateboarding my way off a cliff and then getting up and grinning like a gibbon, while still on fire with fake blood squirting from my scalp and an alligator thrashing my penis from side to side.
best of luck with that glamorous gash on your head. that battle scar is almost as worthy as if it were earned in prison, while being bashed and raped by ten bikies, you should wear it with pride under that strange black blob.
i very much look forward to your next foray into the world of self-mutilation and stupid stunts. i hope next time you fuck up it will be the local governments fault, so that you can sue and have the tax payers pay for your next ten films.

best of luck,
a true fan.

__________________
Ohayo!!!

poopermcgraw

Heh I rationalized all the inconsistencies in my head. For instance, it seemed reasonable to me that somehow the ground or something else in the fall took out a scrap of scalp and skull, and I remember somewhere that facial wounds bleed like the dickens. Also, adrenaline, etc. could account for his seeming quick recovery, then loss of consciousness. We've all heard the story where a kid cuts of his finger in shop class, but acts very calmly until the ambulance arrives and the shock wears off. And I was thinking that black patch was his skull implant covered with some material. I have no idea, I see all of the fakery points you guys were making, but when I was watching it my mind rationalized it.

__________________
Bye.

Phage

bundy
Are you not paying attention? There is an obvious cut during the action which proves that it is a fake. I am betting the black blob is a bladder for fake blood which he glued on for the stunt, and the guy behind him with the box is working with their materials. As for the merit of making the video itself, I have found worse in Blockbuster.

bundy

Phage
read between the lines.

__________________
Ohayo!!!