![]() |
Couple marries, discovers they are twins
LINKY
Quote:
Do you think the courts were right in annulling the marriage? I'm torn. On one hand, the couple is completely innocent in this situation and really didn't deserve this, and I can't even imagine how horrible this is for them. On the other hand, allowing them to stay legally married is sending the message "Incest is OK as long as you don't know you're related!" in which case I'm sure they'd have at least a few couples claiming they "didn't know" or something. *shudder* So sad :( |
Require one of them to be sterilized and let them stay married.
|
Wow.
So: just wow. See, I'm starting to realize that I do things too fast on this great old internet of ours. I miss nuance and subtlety, I go off half cocked based on what I thought I read rather than what's actually there. Case in point: when I read this article earlier today I thought we were talking about conjoined twins who were literally "separated at birth". Wow. Crazy story even just the way it is, though. |
didn't their birthday and time of birth say something to them?
I was born on july 10th '78. me too!! |
Based on some theories for what makes someone attractive, this is not unexpected if twins were separated and later met each other.
|
Drew Curtis of Fark.com has an interesting take on this. He believe the story to be a fiction created by David Alton to further his legislation. Crackpot conspiracy theory? Perhaps.
http://forums.fark.com/cgi/fark/comments.pl?IDBlog=21 Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Not one Star Wars reference? I'm proud, TFP. I really am.
|
Fake or not, its not unexpected that twins should be attracted to each other if they are raised apart, the reasoning is the same as that father daughter marriage that made the general board several months ago.
Incest isn't rare because its 'taboo' but because we instinctively are not sexually attracted to people we grow up with. Remove this and we are more attracted to family members than non-family. |
fresnelly, good catch, thats a great point.
no names and no documents to back it up do seem a bit lacking http://swg.stratics.com/content/lore...ges/ackbar.gif just for you will...just for you. |
wrong reference Shauk
|
How do you know Admiral Ackbar didn't marry his sister?
IT'S A TRAP! |
*shakes head* Oh, Shauk...
http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1008/...ef7c48eb_m.jpg I really hope this story is just something that someone just made up so they had an anecdote to use when trying to pass a piece of legislation. I really do. I also agree with what others are saying: sterilize one and let them stay married. |
This seems a bit too strange. I suppose it could happen, but the conspiracy theory makes more sense to me.
What an odd story, true or not. If it is true, I'm not sure why they'd want to stay married. I would feel very weird. I remember when I was engaged before and there was a chance that we were distantly related. I was ready to break it off. But then, looking back through our families, it wasn't true. |
I thought Oedipus Rex before I thought Star Wars.
You're all a bunch of fucking geeks, you know that? Yeah, I know O. Rex was all about his momma, so back off. |
Quote:
They say that you are most attracted to yourself and you try to find partners that both look and act like you do. So who is most like yourself other than you... your twin, thats who |
All of this talk of sterilization has me somewhat confused.. kids don't come exclusively out of marriage (i.e. you don't need a ring to have sex, thankfully!). What if the woman was pregnant before they got a divorce? Forced abortion?
I would go on a physical anthropology/evolutionary tangent, but I'll leave that alone for now. |
Sorry JumpinJesus, but...
http://img.printfection.com/14/87329/WKrZW.jpg Lucky for you I also love people who can spell Oedipus. ;) |
So now they're just living together? What does this type of thing do to the family structure, I say! They're living in sin, all because their beautiful love wasn't condoned by the state.
Seriously, they're in Tijuana right now enjoying a good donkey show. I can understand the state dissolving their official union due to the precedent that would be set...but after that, I say it's up to the couple involved. If they can look past that nasty little chromosomal linkage, then who would ever know? Of course, if it's a PR move, then there you go. |
|
As an identical twin I don't find this that unusual. Having a twin is like having another of yourself to talk to. And it's great. Finding a female counterpart that is very similar to you would be an awesome relationship. Until you found out she was your sister of course. Otherwise it would be pretty much perfect.
|
"YER MUH SISTER, YER MUH SISTER!" - Joe Dirt
Quote:
|
Quote:
quoted for relevance btw.. seems a lot of people may have missed this post. |
Quote:
well, one of my friends has a boyfriend and they have the same birth date....:sad: I think probably they just thought it was another sign that they were meant to be... It may be quite confusing and overwhelming at first but I imagine if they really love each other, they're not going to let any courft decide whether they stay together or not. I for one prefer to pass no judgment and wish them well - I just think they have to be realistic and make sure they are very careful in terms of ever considering to have kids... |
Meh. Not that big a deal. The 'case' was only brought to light to further the position that sperm donor/IVF/adopted children should know who their real parents are. I disagree with this position, because it may discourage parents giving children up for adoption (instead of an abortion). The problem is just as easily solved with a hash function (sperm donor -> random identifier). The random identifier is given to any child conceived by the sperm donor, along with an (anonymized) medical history. That way, the child knows his medical history, and can identify siblings, but the donor remains anonymous.
Also, I seem to recall reading a few years ago that the problems with inbreeding tend to occur only after a few generations of inbreeding. So, such a couple could have kids without problems (except the 'ew' factor...). I'm too lazy to check the actual research, though, so I could be wrong about that. Meh. Not that big a deal. The 'case' was only brought to light to further the position that sperm donor/IVF/adopted children should know who their real parents are. I disagree with this position, because it may discourage parents giving children up for adoption (instead of an abortion). The problem is just as easily solved with a hash function (sperm donor -> random identifier). The random identifier is given to any child conceived by the sperm donor, along with an (anonymized) medical history. That way, the child knows his medical history, and can identify siblings, but the donor remains anonymous. Also, I seem to recall reading a few years ago that the problems with inbreeding tend to occur only after a few generations of inbreeding. So, such a couple could have kids without problems (except the 'ew' factor...). I'm too lazy to check the actual research, though, so I could be wrong about that. |
Ok... so I'm not sure if it's true or a fake, but I can see how it could be true. I also seem to remember something about European elite marrying twin siblings back in the day, to keep the wealth in the family. I'm not into history, so what do I know.
Seems like they'll have a pretty tight bond from now on, whether they choose to stay together romantically or not. Sounds like a mess, that I wouldn't want to deal with. |
Quote:
|
for those of you that rekon that one of them should be sterilised, there are a few issues that need to be understood and thought about.
1) do we deny someone the right to have children? 2) do we deny someone the right to have children in the event that they get divorced (in this case they did..). 3) assuming that one of them did get strilised, and later decided that the whole situation was too much heartache, and they changed their mind about being together, what gives society the right to withold the gift of children? one thing is for sure though.. the saying about not being able to divorce your family now goes out the window. |
Quote:
Note for you pervs: it has nothing to do with Penthouse Forum Magazine. Although they probably had a letter that dealt with this subject as well, come to think of it. |
Quote:
This is really just wow. I can imagine the psychological effects tied to it, but I think that related children adopted by different parents should know that they have siblings out there in the world. I don't know what should be done when they want to meet them... I think they should be allowed to meet, if nothing else, let them know they aren't alone in the world. |
Sadly, this is one of the reasons that Indiana requires a blood test before two people get married. They don't want anyone marrying their brother/sister/aunt/child.
|
Ew.
That is all. |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 01:45 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2
© 2002-2012 Tilted Forum Project