Thank you so much to all who've responded. Here's what I have, so far. A mixture of what people have suggested both here and on usenet, where I asked the same question...
Good Contenders: (in no particular order)
- Jars of Clay - Flood
- Tori Amos - God
- Collective Soul - Shine
- Genesis - Jesus, He Knows Me
- The Police - Oh My God
- Dishwalla - Counting Blue Cars
- Norman Greenbaum - Spirit in the Sky
- Band Aid - Do They Know it's Christmas?
- XTC - Dear God
- Joan Osborne - What If God was One of Us
- U2 - The Wanderer
- Concrete Blonde - Help Me!
- Rolling Stones - Sympathy for the Devil
- Jewel - Who Will Save Your Soul?
- Leonard Cohen - Hallelujah
- REM - Losing My Religion
- George Harrison - My Sweet Lord
I'm still undecided with Boyz II Men - Dear God, because while it's a nice song about what we own to Him, it's not exactly to my taste. Then again, what's important is what
she likes, not what I like. So, would she enjoy it? I don't know...
I'm also undecided with Andew Lloyed Weber - Jesus Christ Superstar. It's a nice song and all but I'm not sure if it fits in tone, musically, with the rest of the songs. What do you think?
It just occured to me that I could also include INXS - Devil Inside...
Again, I thank everyone who've entered suggestions. I listened to a sample of most of the suggestions offered. If I didn't, it was probably because I couldn't find one, like Nick Cave - There is a Kingdom. This isn't etched in stone, nor is it a Valentine's gift or anything, so more (or better) suggestions are welcome! Comments are, too...
Oh, and thanks,
lucidity.