Thing is, if Ethan had done as I suggested, and formed an alliance with Rupert and Rudy to vote one of the chicks off, then they could have maintained that alliance if they were to go to tribal council again. The next immunity challenge could very well be something non-physical. Besides, nobody can even say that Rudy cost them the immunity challenge, and they won the reward challenge.
Basically I think Ethan made a bad decision in terms of the best thing he could do to ensure his survival, which is to vote off Jenna. He probably was peeved about all the stuff that wasn't going his way (Tina being voted off, fucking up the challenge, not being able to catch fish)
|