Quote:
Originally posted by grumpyolddude
IMO, yes. Contrary to what the Catholic Church tried to drum into me, thoughts cannot be, by themselves, "sin." The manner in which you act upon your thoughts make them "sinful" or not.
|
Untrue. Unconscious thoughts are not sin -- that is, if some idea pops into my head, I'm not responsible for it. But if I dwell upon it, it is sin. Why? Because if I dwell, say, on the fantasy of killing my advisor, there might come a time when I'm not free to not kill him. It might become an obsession, and in any case would make me a worse person. And, of course, that's what sin's about -- whether or not doing something makes you a worse person.