I separated these into catagories to make them easier to address.
Jobs
It's not going to take a genius to realize of all of the jobs people want few jobs will be in high demand. I personally would not want to be a doctor if I would get zero reward for it. I would have as much as a janitor. The downside is I would be obligated to care for everyone, and if I got sick and died because of it my family would get nothing for my risk.
But then, I wouldn't be a doctor, I would want to be the Head Coach of the Philadelphia Eagles. I could get that job, couldn't I? If I couldn't, I don't see what job I would want in the communist system, I don't much care for being worker number 372.
Quote:
|
The motivation to work hard is no longer to get more reward, you work hard out of pride, out of creativity, and because human nature of 99% of people is to do well and want to do a good job. If there are people who just want to bum around, they will probably find themselves doing jobs that arent very interesting, the manual work - but we will always make sure there is a chance to improve for everyone, that no one is stuck anywhere.
|
Why would I want to work hard when I get the same no matter what? If my chance at being the Eagles HC is gone, then what is stopping me from doing some extremely basic meanial job and slacking off at every possible instance? I would get the same amount of "pay" no matter what, correct? So, I get a job where I work with friends, do zero work, and we get the same amount of "pay" that the person who busts their ass because of "human nature". It would not take long for people to figure this out.
Property
What about a person who enjoys to hunt? Could they possibly get a piece of private land "according to their needs"?
What about a person who has strong roots to an area, plans to have a family, and doesn't want to move?
I could go on and on, but one key point is, in order to start, almost EVERYONE will have to move. So, please explain to me how people would begin to embrace this? This also needs to take into consideration that a good number of houses will be trashed when the family leaves. Why? "I ain't going ot be living here anymore, no need to clean up, no incentive to keep in good condition...PARTY TIME!"
Acceptance
Now, please explain to me again WHY people would accept this. A fact is that many people's job training will become absolutely meaningless. People's houses would be taken from them.
From a pure mathmatical perspective, 50% of people would hate this because they lose in changing to this system. Reading all everything you have said so far, I have gained zero reasons why I would possibly want to switch to communism, and many new reasons why to hate communism. So please, do me a favor and just say what someone like me would gain.