Quote:
Originally posted by Mr.Deflok
I am very, very surprised at the lack of posts in this thread, the Reloaded thread amassed a huge number of posts in a short amount of time, then again more people hated that film and the haters are always the most vocal.
|
The answer to your dilemma is that it was a “good” film. Not a great film.
It is true that it is much easier to hate. But it is also rather hard to praise something, which is not quite praise worthy.
I would give it a 7.5/10. Then again I am not a Tolken fan; just because he was the first of the fantasy genre doesn’t mean he is the best. So since I am not a Tolken fan I must judge the movie as a movie. It was defiantly better then the past two films. The story telling was at its best. The story developments and character interaction between all the action scenes was the most intresting part of the movie in my opinion. There were weak points though, besides Elijah Woods, but I wont spoil the movie by listing them.
BTW 7.5 does make it worth seeing in the theater.
Cheers.