I'll have to say that the only movie that has had me creeped out recently is The Shining. We watched it three times in a row on Halloween last year, and every fucking time it got me. I had never seen it before. I've seen The Ring since then, and it simply wasn't as scary as everyone says. My brother did tell me a few things about it, but he said it still should have been scary as hell. And it wasn't.
I watched it at 9:00 PM in the dark as well!
The Shining just had the whole "big mansion nobody here but ghosts and a psycho" thing going. Retro Crush's scariest movie moments of all time had the scariest part of The Shining: when the wife is running up the stairs of the mansion away from Jack, and she looks across the hall. You see a doorway, and inside the door is a man sitting on the couch with another man in a bear-suit kneeling down in front of him staring STRAIGHT at the camera. People who've seen this scene probably know what I'm talking about. Me and my 21 year old friend almost pissed our pants and had heart attacks simultaneously just because of that one scene. The "weird" parts of that movie were way scarier than the actual "scary" parts.
-Lasereth