Tilted Forum Project Discussion Community - View Single Post - SOUTH PARK vs. THE SIMPSONS: May the best cartoon win

sadatx · 08-08-2003, 11:02 PM

So herein we find out once and for all which of these two fine contenders will trump the other in the history books.

Try to judge what you feel is the BEST of The Simpsons against the BEST of South Park.

It seems unfair to have the current episodes go head to head since many people feel that The Simpsons isn't as consistently good as it once was.

My vote would have to go to The Simpsons. It just seems to have more heart than South Park. And since reruns are plentiful it's easy to see how good The Simpsons once was. This is not to say that I don't love South Park. It's just when forced to choose I think The Simpson edges it out IMHO.

Please don't list the pros and cons of each without choosing a clear winner. The point of this thread is to pick a winner. You must choose.

So go now and choose wisely.

08-08-2003, 11:02 PM	#1 (permalink)
sadatx Psycho	SOUTH PARK vs. THE SIMPSONS: May the best cartoon win So herein we find out once and for all which of these two fine contenders will trump the other in the history books. Try to judge what you feel is the BEST of The Simpsons against the BEST of South Park. It seems unfair to have the current episodes go head to head since many people feel that The Simpsons isn't as consistently good as it once was. My vote would have to go to The Simpsons. It just seems to have more heart than South Park. And since reruns are plentiful it's easy to see how good The Simpsons once was. This is not to say that I don't love South Park. It's just when forced to choose I think The Simpson edges it out IMHO. Please don't list the pros and cons of each without choosing a clear winner. The point of this thread is to pick a winner. You must choose. So go now and choose wisely.