|
it's ridiculous how obviously circular that argument is. i really can't believe you can't see it.
7. But then God exists necessarily in that possible world.
8. So God exists in all possible worlds.
how can you make that leap from 7 to 8? god only exists in the possible worlds in which he exists, and those are also the only possible worlds in which it is NECESSARY that he exists. watch what happens if i change number 6 and do the same crap you did..
6. God possibly does not exist. Let's cash this out as "There is a possible world in which God does not exist."
7. But then God does not exist in that possible world.
8. So God does not exist in any possible world.
9. The actual world is a possible world.
10. Therefore, God does not exist in the actual world.
|