I'll take a look at the other thread, but i'd say for openers that when the God of Abraham was first worshiped, there was no conception of a conscious afterlife, mearly descent in to the depths of Sheol.
Moreover, there is no proof that since we can understand the organic nature of the brain, that there is no soul. That was my analogy. There seemed be the instant jump between saying that since there is a physical brain, there can be no metaphysical soul. I don't see the logic there.
|