Tilted Forum Project Discussion Community - View Single Post

SiN · 07-02-2003, 09:40 AM

google found this -

Quote:

who and whom.__Who do you think is coming to the party? Whom did you give the invitations to? The traditional rules that determine the use of who and whom are relatively simple: who is used for a grammatical subject, where a nominative pronoun such as I or he would be appropriate, and whom is used as the object of a verb or preposition. Thus, we write The actor who played Hamlet was excellent, since who stands for the subject of played Hamlet, and Who do you think is the best candidate? where who stands for the subject of is the best candidate. But we write To whom did you give the letter? since whom is the object of the preposition to, and The man whom the papers criticized did not show up, since whom is the object of the verb criticized.
____1
__This all seems straightforward enough, but with complicated sentences it is not so easy. A sentence such as I met the man whom the government had tried to get France to extradite requires you to have thought the sentence through before you have written it—you should know from the start that whom will be the object of the verb extradite, which is several clauses away. It is hard to be this calculating on a consistent basis, so it’s not surprising that writers from Shakespeare onward often use who and whom interchangeably. In speech and informal writing, people tend to use who, even as the object of a verb or preposition. A sentence such as Who did John say he was going to support? is perfectly natural, despite violating the traditional rules. Using whom often sounds forced or pretentiously correct, as in Whom shall I say is calling? or Whom did you give it to? Nevertheless, many writers adhere to the rules, especially in formal style. These rules apply in the same manner to whoever and whomever.
____2
who in restrictive and nonrestrictive clauses.__The relative pronoun who may be used in restrictive clauses, in which case it is not preceded by a comma, or in nonrestrictive clauses, in which case a comma is required. Thus you can say either The scientist who discovers a cure for cancer will be immortalized, where the clause who discovers a cure for cancer indicates which scientist will be immortalized, or The mathematician over there, who solved the four-color theorem, is widely known, where the clause who solved the four-color theorem adds information about a person already identified by the phrase the mathematician over there.

hope it helps