I was actually looking at starting a physical reading club at my house based on the top 100-200 books lists
http://www.tfproject.org/tfp/tilted-...00-novels.html
and
http://www.tfproject.org/tfp/tilted-...-you-read.html
I missed the round for the Zen Motorcycle but I'd be up for a book for January.
Another suggestion might be from the Eye Opener's reading list, pick 1 book per month from a different category, so there is a little more variety in the types and might get a wider berth of folks.
A couple I've been eying that I'd like to get read sometime this year:
Clockwork Orange
Slaughterhouse 5
on the Road
Earthsea Trilogy