Quote:
Originally Posted by Idyllic
You can read more about the IL-legality of this in the Constitution itself.
Yes, but it was My Choice to Buy the car, no one forced it upon me, no one forced me to own a car. This "Health Care" Will be different, you will pay, they will make you pay, whether you want to or not. That's like forcing a blind person to buy a car just because everyone else has to.
Totally not the same as auto insurance. because you can drive a car without insurance, without a license, without anything as long as you don't get caught (I'm not saying that's right, just true, it's your choice), there is NO CHOICE here "regulated, mandated health insurance" they will know how much you owe, when you owe it, when you pay it, if you do or do not pay it and if you don't, they will take it form you one way or another, that's unconstitutional......
Great, just one more person i will have to pay for.
|
Where exactly in the constitution does it say it's illegal to mandate health insurance? And back to the having a choice about car insurance thing, you also have the choice not to work. If you choose not to work you won't have to pay for health insurance yourself.
---------- Post added at 04:04 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:02 PM ----------
Quote:
Originally Posted by dksuddeth
constitutional scholar is a useless term. Over the last 150 years I've seen 'scholars' define the constitution in such twisted and tortured ways that it's beyond belief. why do we keep referring such important issues to 'sholars'?
as i've stated many times, because of mainstream politicos worship of big government power, the power to tax has been broadened to such an extent that congress can now mandate that you plant roses or morning glories in your front yard. I hardly think that this kind of power was intended by the framers of the constitution.
|
I don't understand how you can say there are no constitutional scholars, but you seem to proclaim yourself one(though not with those exact words) you seem to think your view of the constitution is the only one that matters and people who's job it is to interprit the constitution are dead wrong.