I respect everyones opinion here and I guess most will classify me as a cinematic novice but I loved every aspect of this movie.
In the end arent movies a piece of someone's art expressed through a medium of multiple senses.
Most movies are inspired by other works. Kind of like todays music which seems it has all been done. Its not to say some movies are may be made with the direct goal of making money.
Could he have done things differently? Doesnt that possibly come close to: should this movie have been made it all? I for one am glad it was.