Felix, most women have cellulite somewhere. It just happens. I've met super-skinny girls who were freaked out by "orange peel" skin on their asses.
And once you get it, it's super hard to lose as a female. I won't say anything for men, because I don't know.
I don't like super-cut persons of either gender.
I considered myself obese at 220, and completely unhealthy at 128. I looked like my head was going to fall off my neck. It was obscene. But a lot of people still feel that 5'6" and 128 is a "healthy" weight. That being said, even when I had a strong muscular base, I looked "bigger" than average because of the extra looseness from when I weighed significantly more.
I'd rather be healthy and strong, no matter what it makes me look like compared to the atractiveness average. I've moved from building muscle to working on endurance partly because the moment I failed to properly address a muscle group, that area got big and soft. Which annoyed me personally. I don't know what it did to my perceived attractiveness. It makes me sad that my ex could not see past part of the weight issue and focused on poundage (there were other issues that compounded this) than health.
He fell out when I told him that in one of the pictures that he felt I looked "a little too skinny" I was at 143.
Ack, off topic. I am attracted to people that are comfortable in their skin, real, not afraid to walk around with clothes off and those who focus on their health. Not to obsession, but are conscious. I loved him when he was 220 and paunchy and when he was 195 and significantly trimmer and muscular. I like really, really strong healthy brains, too... not chubby brains.