I wear:
Ungaro III
And:
Pi
Not at the same time, of course. The Ungaro III is more 'spice and smoke' smelling, while Pi is more vanilla-ey.
Also some stuff from
BPAL - my favorite of these so far is 'Oberon'.
Oh - Almost forgot to give a shout-out to MSD's awesome advice in the 'Ask A Cologne Snob' thread. He recommended both the Ungaro III and the Pi, and I'm quite happy with both.