Quote:
Originally Posted by Zeraph
Woa, so now that we know Nameless (the guy jacob talked to in the start and that wants to kill him) can change shape (him being Locke all this time, Locke is dead ), combined with the comment by the latina chick Allana or whatever, that Jacob's shack had been used by a pretender...i think if we look back we'll see Nameless' hand in almost everything. I think he was pretending to be Christian and was messing with Locke that whole time. And guess who else got manipulated by some dead person...Ben by his supposed daughter's spirit...right after the smoke monster. Soooo if you could follow all that, I think Nameless is the smoke monster. In other words, dead characters like Christian have never really come back to life. It was Nameless pretending to be them the whole time. Which makes sense if you think back. Like Mr Echo was right! It wasn't his brother! So the smoke monster/Nameless killed him because he figured it out.
|
Woah! But... THEIR BODIES ARE ALL ON THE ISLAND!!! So maybe whatever this thing is can only impersonate people whose bodies are available to him?
Christian's body left its coffin and was never found.
Locke's body just fell out of a box.
Alex's body presumably never left the island.
Yemmi's body was in the Beechcraft.
This fits very nicely with the "talking with the dead" themes they've been working via Hurley and Miles. Miles has to have physical proximity on the body too...