I'd comepletely forgotten this thread of mine, fun to see it again!
Ed Norton, Shia Labeouf and Jermaine from Conchords are three mentioned that could be added to my inexplicable list.
As for a couple new ones for me: Bill the vampire (Stepen Moyer) from True Blood. Not my type at all, a little too chiseled in the face, but when the fang's come out, RAWR!! There's just something so primal in his eye's, can't be easy to pull off. MMM, hot vampire sex.
Bill Maher. He is
extremely inexplicable to me, a scrawy, short guy with a big head, big nose and greasy hair. It can only be explained by his wit, sarcasm and the fact that I agree with him 80% of the time. Even so, I still don't get myself.
And you guys that said Flo from the Progressive commercials, I think that's funny, even though I don't think she's very good looking or sexy, I've noticed she definately has a look goin' on.