ahhh, that was a huge clue, unc.
The Old Original Bookbinder's......?
As you may know, it was closed down for quite a while recently but has now reopened. In spite of all the "tourist trap" B.S. about it, it is a classic old restaurant, the classic old waiters rounded out the atmosphere, and under favorable conditions there I've had a few of the best lobsters I've ever had.
I like the bar in there, too. I've had many a fine martini and manhattan in there while smoking a nice big cigar.