|
Rekna, private entities can't take votes away. That's the point you are missing. All private entities can do is either (1) try to persuade the govt not to recognize certain voters as acceptable based on noncompliance with established criteria, in which case either the govt can accept that position or not, or (2) go directly to the voter and in a legal manner try to persuade the voter not to vote or to vote as the private entity advocates (that means no lying, which is fraud, and no threats). There are existing statutes that prohibit misconduct in the course of both those categories of activities. In light of that, what additional restriction are you advocating in terms of "caging" that are not already illegal?
As for the selective recounts, my position is NOT that the Gore forces didn't have the right to go to the counties they chose in order to advocate for recounts selectively. They had the right to do that and it's not a crime. What you're advocating is that the private nongovernmental entity - the Gore campaign - didn't have the right to pick and choose where they would advocate to have the recounts done on a selective basis. Of course they had that right. And the other side, by the same token, had the right to advocate that either there's a recount everywhere or a recount nowhere. The govt ultimately does the counting, and it's bound by law to comply with whatever the applicable legal standards are. But that tells you nothing about the scope of private people's right to advocate a standard other than the one that ultimately is followed.
The flaw in your logic is that you're collapsing what private people have the right to do with what govt is obligated to do. Very different issues.
As far as Republicans going after blacks because they are Democrats, can we agree that if black voting patterns went majority Republican, the practices you're complaining about wouldn't be happening? And if that's the case, then what the GOP operatives are doing is not tied to the fact that the voters are black but to the fact that they tend Democrat. If they were black and tended Republican this wouldn't happen. So it's not racial discrimination at all.
|