I'll go for nay.
However, I wouldn't like skinny girls either.
standard sized girls, maybe a small tummy tops is where it's at!
EDIT:
just saw that pic.
C is chubby?
Hell.. C all the way! B too.. They're probably even. A is a no. (although in reality a yes
)
I'd say even more than C was still attractive. She's not chubby at all.