I'm naturally disinclined to pay much attention to MADD, since somewhere along the way (probably when the "DD" went from "Drunk Driving" to "Destructive Decisions") it seems like the organization was taken over by
Sheila Broflovski.
But since there seem to be conflicting reports about how this thing works, I'm withholding judgment. If I was a student, I would probably find the version in the original post angering, and the one on the other site just annoying and not worth paying attention to.
Of course, I also never EVER drink enough to have this be an issue and am smart enough to understand the consequences of such an action (at least I believe I am), so that is where my opinion is coming from.
I'm sure if I was a parent my view would be at least somewhat different (though likely not all the way to actually supporting any of this).