This is the last I've got to say on the matter, because going in circles makes me dizzy. It has occurred to me, however, that much of the seeming vitriol present here stems from what appears to be a disconnect in the argument itself. Nobody has and nobody will defend inappropriate behaviour. What follows, then, is quibbling over what precisely constitutes appropriate behaviour.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mixedmedia
I'm not holding onto the past. You're taking my remark into an unintended context. I was responding to aberkok's conversation with will about gender inequality. I am not saying that my argument is resting on the historical oppression of women, but to say that it has no impact on this issue is, in my opinion, willful ignorance.
|
I didn't state or even intend to imply that you were 'holding onto the past.' This is, in fact, precisely why I'd asked you to clarify; I was unclear regarding your stance here.
Accepting the proper place of the past events is a tricky business at the best of times. I'm all for learning from past mistakes, but I'd rather avoid having to atone for the sins of my father. This was the general statement I was trying to make and was not intended as a specific attack against anyone.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mixedmedia
I'm with abaya in that this is all about respect. You can talk 'til your blue in the face about respecting a woman's equality, but as long as you're okay with every woman around you being available for 'male bonding exercises' and 'childish fun' (as long as they aren't your sister, of course) then it's all just blah, blah, blah.
|
I've clearly offended you and for that I apologize. On the other hand, it's simply not in my nature to hide myself or lie about who I am. I like looking at attractive women. Sometimes I have lascivious thoughts about them, and sometimes I choose to express that. The form it takes is dependent entirely on the company I find myself in.
Quote:
Originally Posted by abaya
I don't care about objectification--IN THE MIND. I don't care about people having sexual THOUGHTS about others. Got it?
|
Actually, this is precisely what I
don't get.
As stated above I am a fairly simple man and believe in honesty in all things. It's a high standard that I set for myself and I do strive towards it at all times. I am fully capable of recognizing that there are certain thoughts that are appropriate to voice in certain contexts that may be inappropriate in others. This is basic etiquette, and is not a difficult concept.
On the other hand, I fail to recognize the difference between thinking something sexual and saying it. The words, after all, are merely an extension of the thought, which exists regardless of whether or not it's expressed. These thoughts are a part of human nature and need to be handled tactfully, but repressing them completely seems somehow dishonest to me.
I would not tell a woman who I'd just met that she had great tits. It may be true, but it's not appropriate. I may tell her that she looks lovely. At it's core, these are really the same thing, in that I am expressing an appreciation of physical beauty. How I choose to express it depends largely on my audience, and therefore the social situation I find myself in. The words themselves are more a product of environment than thought process, which remains largely the same regardless of who I'm speaking with. I would go so far as to contend that any man who makes such lewd comments to a woman is suffering from nothing more than a failure to understand proper social boundaries, which judging by your above statements would seem to be something we agree on (though I'm loathe to assume it and will of course be open to any contradiction on the matter).
And really that's what I'm getting at here. The thoughts are normal and the words are just words. Some guys are ill-mannered and as a consequence choose the wrong ones, but they're not inherently harmful. The thought processes behind them may be, but of course it's ludicrous to think that we can paint half the Earth's population with the same brush.
And that really is all I have to say about that.