It took me a second to figure out this was the most anticipated PC games only.
Anyway, Steve my have left Starcraft 2 off his list, but Charles billed it at #5 on his. Personally, I'm amazed at Alan Wake on both lists. I thought it was being developed for the 360 with an unmentioned PC port later.
All and all I'd agreed both are good lists, I'd just number a few things differently.
My personal big four. The rest of the games aren't really on my radar.
#1 Fallout 3 (It's a sequel to one my favorite PC RPG series. 'nuff said)
#2 Starcraft II ( It's Starcraft)
#3 Rise of the Argonauts (I'm a sucker for mythology)
#4 Far Cry 2 (the previews got me)