Originally Posted by Mondak

I thought about starting another thread for this, but what the heck - here goes:

I think the Giants won DESPITE Eli Manning's performance, not because of it. He was 55% on completions and looked shaky most of the game. How about someone like Antonio Pierce for MVP instead? The Giants managed 17 points. Can't say that their offense won the game for them here. Giving the MVP to the QB is a cop out.