Originally Posted by QuasiMondo

I don't think you can be considered one of the best ever unless you're able to build a dynasty.

Montana, Aikman, Brady, those are greatest ever (and any other QB who's been part of a SB dynasty).

Numbers are good, but as a QB, you have to do more than just put numbers up. That kind of stuff may work fine for wide recievers, running backs, and linebackers, but as the head honcho of your team, you have to deliver, and to be considered greatest ever, you have to deliver again and again. Any QB that doesn't have a Lombardi trophy on his mantle doesn't make my list, and any QB that doesn't have at least two trophies is going to be a hard sell for me.