Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Cynthetiq
jenna, my point is that YOU have any filters, that's the example since you stated seeing something like this makes YOU feel bad about this situation taking into consideration the history YOU are adding to it.
|
Cyn, you're proving my point exactly. This is what I was talking about with regards to environment, in a particular region. Sure, those white-hooded dudes are harmless *in their particular context,* (in this case, Spain) which does NOT consider them to be threatening figures whatsoever. However, put them in a different context, that of the American South, and YES, they white hood give much offense, and rightly so. This is where something called cultural relativism (anthro 101) comes in. You look at something IN ITS OWN CONTEXT before you even get close to judging it.
What you are doing is projecting something completely out of its own context, and testing Jenna by asking what her interpretation is, *based on her own context.* I don't see how this helps prove any point of yours, to be honest, and I don't see its relevance to the OP's issue at all. The article is not about a fake body being hung up in a tree in Spain, or Norway, or wherever... and the NAACP get pissy about it from the US... which would, indeed, be absurd (which is the analogy you seem to attempting to make). The issue is about a fake body, very similar to a lynched one, being hung up in a very particular area of the American south, which has a very particular history and context, where YES, the imagery DOES still have power. I mean, come on! Is it really so hard to understand?!?! Seriously, WTF people.