07-24-2007, 01:58 PM
|
#119 (permalink)
|
|
Walking is Still Honest
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by kutulu
Spoiler: Looking at the wand would tell what the spell was, not the result. All three of them were casting spells at each other.
|
I think SF's right on this point, actually.
Spoiler: Anyone more clearly remember the part when Harry realized that Voldemort would discover the snapping of Harry's wand? Iirc, Harry or Hermione explains that Voldemort would examine her wand and discover that the last spell missed its intended target and hit Harry's wand. If I'm not mis-remembering this, then, the wand does show the result of the spell.
But SF, Spoiler: the way I read it, it was a pure accident - not even manslaughter - if Dumbledore was responsible, and Dumbledore didn't examine the wand because he just didn't want to know.
Either way, his responsibility was for an accident, not an intentional killing.
__________________
I wonder if we're stuck in Rome.
|
|
|