Quote:
|
Originally Posted by yellowmac
Now, would the pilot have been Penny had Desmond let Charlie die?
|
It's not possible that the pilot would have been Penny had Desmond let Charlie die. The pilot was already on the island and hanging from the tree by the time we get to the scene where Charlie is "supposed" to die. Whether or not Charlie lives or dies only influences what happens after that point. So, Charlie living or dying can only affect whether or not the pilot is alive or dead, which is why...
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by ratbastid
That's clearly what Des thinks.
|
...I disagree with that. I think Desmond only regretted letting Charlie live when he thought the pilot was dead hanging from the tree. Now that the pilot is alive, he has nothing to regret since Charlie living or dying couldn't have influenced who the pilot was. Obviously, had the pilot been Penny and also been dead, Desmond would have been questioning his decision.
-Tamerlain