*does happy dance at finding the BSG thread*
I, too, refuse to look at Chief, Colonel Tigh, Tori and Anders as cylons. It's weird. I read the interview with Moore (?) and could see - sorta - why they'd say these people are cylons but I still like the prophet theory better.
Though, each theory has holes in it IMO. Cause Starbuck is a prophet and Baltar is a what? There's only 5 prophets and 5 final cylons. Oh - just realized this. Does Madam President count as a prophet already?
edit: just saw uber's post. I remember that in the interview these four are noted as being fundamentally different cylons.... maybe they are half earthling half cylon?
