A few things first about Watada: bottom line, he was wrong to base his defense on the illegality of the war. He can't challenge the judgement of congress in a military court, which is why the judge refused to allow witnesses (pertaining to the il/legality of the war). The prosecution mishandled the case when they brought in Watada's conflicting stipulation of fact because arguing the il/legality of the war before a military jury is not permitted. Thus a mistrial. And Watada is a weasel.
As to the UN: If the idea is to nitpick and ignore world affairs, true enough. The questions remains as to why the UN wouldn't find Sadaam in violation. When in actuality, they did. Repeatedly. They have seventeen resolutions, and each of the last sixteen started with the preamble that Iraq was in violation of 1441 and needed to come into compliance.
The issue wasn't whether Iraq was in violation -- it was -- or whether the UN would find it in violation -- it did. The issue was whether the UN would back its word by actually doing something about it other than another sternly-worded resolution. If one wants to be a nit-picking grain-lawyer one can continue to complain that what the US did under 'international law' was wrong because we didn't ask 'mother may we' from the UN.
And perhaps you know the reason for that: Saddam had succeeded in bribing the French and Russians to the point that they would vote 'no'. The French certainly weren't principled about this (for them it was all about oil), and the Russians had any number of secrets to hide, arms smuggling foremost if the past is any guide. So the question for you to answer, in turn, is whether you would allow unprincipled, lying, thieving states to stymie you from doing what you believe must be done.
So to the chorus of "unilateral and illegal war of aggression", I say: Yes unilaterally, with a couple dozen other countries in support. Legally, per our Constitution. George Bush didn't allow the lying, thieving French and unprincipled Russians to stop him from doing what he knew had to be done. Bravo.
|