Originally Posted by Bossnass

Ok.

From Pleasant Bay:

You can't be further north and west and still be on Cape Breton.

You can't be west a little bit and hit Newfoundland.

But the soil is a little reddish, so not Quebec proper.

Therefore, I conclude that it must be Madaline Island. Er, I mean "Iles de la Madeleine".

But then again, I wouldn't be surprised if someone told me again that . Of course, with no one else trying, I should get it eventually.