|
How about when Member Y claims a special insight into the personality and/or motivation of Member X? For example, let's say I claim that the reason you support the current war is because you "obviously hate Muslims." Or, what if I make a statement like "you obviously hope to [insert malevolent desire here], which leave no other conclusion open but that you [insert malevolent personal judgement here]." Isn't this an appeal to personal considerations rather than to logic or reason? And shouldn't it be considered "out-of-bounds" in this forum?
__________________
Ceterum censeo Carthaginem esse delendam.
|