What about reel to reel?
LP: Elton John - Don't shoot me I'm only the Piano Player (and I'm not responsible for this title)
Cassette: Def Leppard - High & Dry (my very first prerecorded, on a road trip)
CD: The Dark Side of the Moon, to replace yet another worn out LP of same
I'm not counting cassettes made of my LPs, hand-me-downs, or random things that may have landed in our house. Just first purchases.
Did somebody say "Bay City Rollers?"

