|
Well I don't know that I've done what you are accusing me of doing. Yes there are limits to freedom of speech. I can't yell fire in a theater, for example. . .Unless of course, there actually is a fire. But that's because doing so would put others in danger and could get someone killed. The obsenity issue is still pretty hotly contested. It's pretty hard to find someone who got jailed for saying "shit," however.
Libel/slander are interesting, but I don't think they weaken my argument. Libel and slander are defined as publications/speeches which are false, are known to be false, and are said anyway in order to harm someone else. Again it goes back to actual measurable harm. In the theater case, people can get trampled. In the libel/slander case, people's lives - at the very least their economic lives- can be ruined.
I think you'd have a tough time showing actual measurable economic or physical harm endured by people at a funeral because some idiot is out protesting outside the cemetery. You could easilly show that they were offended. You could show that they were upset. But the law does not hold that offending or upsetting someone is a crime.
This action is essentially trying to criminilize causing offense. The 1st clearly was not meant as "you can say what you want as long as no one's upset about it."
|